Chapter 16 - The Question Alexander Finally Asked

Alexander had spent weeks asking what he missed.
Then Evie’s therapist suggested a different question.
“What did Evie need that she did not get?”
He thought about it all night.
The next morning, he made pancakes.
Evie entered the kitchen wearing mismatched socks.
“Why are they shaped like states?”
“They are circles.”
“That one is definitely New Jersey.”
“Eat your geography.”
She sat.
Alexander placed the plate down and joined her.
After a few minutes he said, “Can I ask you something?”
Evie became cautious.
“It’s not about the investigation.”
“Okay.”
“When I was away before all this, what did you need from me?”
She stared at the pancake.
“I don’t know.”
“That’s okay.”
“Would you get mad?”
“No.”
“What if it makes you feel bad?”
“That’s mine to handle.”
Evie looked at him.
“I needed you to call me, not Rebecca.”
He nodded.
“I needed you to ask me questions when she was there.”
“What kind?”
“Like what I ate. But not just, ‘Did you eat?’ Because if she was
listening, I had to say yes.”
Alexander’s throat tightened.
“What could I have asked?”
Evie thought.
“Maybe, ‘What was the best thing you ate today?’”
He understood.
A question requiring detail.
“And if I said ‘I don’t remember,’ you could know something was wrong.”
He nodded again.
“What else?”
“When I said I wanted you home, you always told me how many days were
left.”
“I thought that helped.”
“It made me feel like I had to survive the days.”
Alexander looked down.
“I’m sorry.”
Evie shrugged, but her eyes were wet.
He did not reach for her immediately.
He let her choose.
After a moment, she put her hand on his.
“I know.”
It was not forgiveness for everything.
It was connection.
Later that day, Coach Foster called Alexander about Evie’s return to
full P.E. participation.
“She’s physically doing better.”
“Thank you.”
“She did the work.”
“You caught her.”
“I happened to be there.”
“You asked the question.”
Emily paused.
“What question?”
“When was the last time you ate?”
“Oh.”
Alexander’s voice softened.
“I keep thinking about that.”
“So does she.”
“I should have asked it.”
Emily did not reassure him falsely.
“Maybe.”
Alexander appreciated the answer.
Then Emily said, “But you can ask the next question.”
That became his rule.
Not to rewrite the past.
Ask the next question.
At the legal level, Rebecca’s case moved toward resolution. Her attorney
and prosecutors discussed possible outcomes, including a negotiated
plea, while the family court maintained protective conditions.
Alexander told his attorney he would not demand a theatrical punishment.
“I want accountability that protects Evie.”
“That may include a plea, probationary conditions, treatment
requirements, and continued restrictions, depending on what prosecutors
and the court accept.”
“I don’t want Evie dragged through a trial if it can be avoided.”
“That will be part of the discussion.”
When Alexander told Evie, carefully and age-appropriately, that adults
were trying to resolve the case without making her repeat everything in
a courtroom, she asked, “Does that mean Rebecca gets away with it?”
“No.”
“Does it mean she admits it?”
“That’s what I want any agreement to require.”
Evie nodded.
“Then okay.”
A week later, Helen Ward contacted prosecutors.
Rebecca was prepared to accept responsibility for intentionally
withholding meals as punishment and for interfering with Evie’s
communication with Alexander.
But she wanted one concession.
She wanted to write Evie one final letter.
Not to be delivered immediately.
To be held until Evie, her therapist, and her father agreed she was
ready.
The request went to Alexander.
He stared at it for a long time.
Then he asked Evie’s therapist the only question that mattered.
“Could saying yes hurt her?”
The therapist replied, “Not if Evie controls whether she ever reads it.”
So Alexander agreed.
May you like
For once, Rebecca would write something she could not force Evie to
receive.