Chapter 18 - Be Brave

The message recovered from Evren’s tablet was only nine words long.
Seraphine read them in Detective Ward’s office.
She’s going downstairs. Be brave. Don’t let her win.
Sent from Adrian at 6:18 p.m.
The timing was exact.
The interior camera showed Seraphine beginning her descent at 6:18.
The live-view log showed Adrian connected from the forestry turnout.
The message reached Evren seconds later.
Ward placed another printout on the table.
Evren had replied:
I’ll make her stop.
Adrian responded with a thumbs-up.
Nothing more.
No order to push.
No explicit instruction to hurt.
But the meaning of the exchange sat in the room like a loaded object.
“How was this not found before?” Seraphine asked.
“The tablet had been factory-reset the morning after the fall,” Ward said. “A cloud backup retained app data the reset did not erase.”
“Who reset it?”
“Adrian’s account initiated the reset at 8:11 a.m.”
Nina leaned back, furious.
Ward continued. “This strengthens an evidence-tampering theory and the manipulation case. Prosecutors are still evaluating exactly which charges fit.”
Seraphine looked at the thumbs-up.
A tiny symbol.
A father’s approval.
The thing Evren had been chasing.
Later that week, Seraphine saw Evren again with Laurel and a child therapist named Dr. Amaya Chen.
Evren already knew investigators had recovered the message.
He sat rigidly in his chair.
“I remembered it,” he said.
“Why didn’t you tell them?” Seraphine asked.
“I thought it made it worse.”
“It does make some things worse.”
He nodded miserably.
Dr. Chen spoke gently. “Worse for whom?”
Evren thought.
“For Dad.”
“And what about for you?”
“I don’t know.”
“You received a message telling you to be brave and not let Seraphine win. What did you think your father wanted?”
Evren stared at the carpet.
“He wanted me to tell her I knew about the paper.”
“Anything else?”
“He wanted her to be scared.”
Seraphine’s breath caught.
“How do you know that?” Dr. Chen asked.
“Because he said before that if she knew I was against her, she might leave.”
“When did he say that?”
“A lot.”
Evren finally looked at Seraphine.
“I thought I was helping him.”
Seraphine kept her voice steady.
“You chose to push me.”
He nodded.
“Yes.”
“Your father’s message did not move your hands.”
“No.”
“But he lied to you and encouraged the confrontation.”
“Yes.”
Dr. Chen watched both of them.
Evren began twisting his sleeve.
“Do you wish I hadn’t told the truth?”
Seraphine frowned. “Why would I?”
“Because then Dad might go to jail.”
There it was again: the false choice.
Truth or family.
Accountability or love.
Seraphine leaned forward slightly.
“You can love your father and tell the truth about him.”
Evren’s eyes filled.
“Even if the truth hurts him?”
“Yes.”
“That doesn’t feel like love.”
“Sometimes love is not protection from consequences.”
Dr. Chen said nothing, allowing the sentence to settle.
Evren wiped his eyes.
“What if he hates me?”
Seraphine answered with care.
“Then that would be his choice. Not proof that you did something wrong by telling the truth.”
For several minutes, the room was quiet.
Then Evren asked something Seraphine did not expect.
“When the baby comes, can I give it something?”
Her instinct was to say yes immediately.
Instead she asked, “What?”
“I don’t know yet.”
“That’s okay.”
He nodded.
After the session, Dr. Chen walked Seraphine to the elevator.
“He is beginning to separate responsibility from identity,” she said. “That will take time.”
“So will I.”
“Yes.”
Seraphine placed a hand beneath her belly as the elevator doors opened.
Behind her, Evren called her name.
She turned.
He stood in the doorway of the therapy room.
May you like
“I’m glad you didn’t leave,” he said.
Then he disappeared back inside before she could answer.