Chapter 8 - Two Women, One Version of the Truth

Claire called Alyssa at four that afternoon.
“Alyssa, it’s Claire.”
Claire was near the front windows, one hand holding the phone, the other resting at her side.
Grant stepped into the hall.
She saw him.
“I listened to your voicemail. If there’s something you believe I should know, you can tell me directly.”
Grant’s pulse accelerated.
Claire listened.
“No, I don’t want screenshots first.”
Another pause.
“Yes. Tonight is fine.”
Grant moved closer.
Claire’s eyes remained on him.
“Seven thirty.”
She ended the call.
“What did you just do?”
Claire slipped the phone into her pocket.
“I invited her here.”
Grant stared at her.
“Why?”
“Because I’m tired of learning about my marriage in pieces.”
“You don’t know what she wants.”
“Neither do you.”
“I know her better than you do.”
Claire’s expression was almost sad.
“That has not been reassuring so far.”
Grant lowered his voice.
“She may be angry.”
“She probably is.”
“She may lie.”
“So might you.”
Claire turned toward the stairs.
Grant followed.
“You don’t need to do this.”
“I do.”
“No, you want to.”
Claire stopped and looked back.
“Do you hear yourself?”
He did.
Grant pressed his lips together.
“What happens if she says something you can’t forgive?”
Claire’s face became still.
“Then it was already true before she said it.”
At seven twenty-eight, headlights crossed the front windows.
Grant stood in the foyer.
Claire remained in the sitting room beside the fireplace.
The arrangement was almost identical to the night before, except this time Grant was waiting for another woman to enter his house.
The bell rang.
Claire opened the door.
Alyssa Rowan stood on the step in a dark wool coat, rain shining on her shoulders.
She looked at Grant first.
Then Claire.
“Thank you for letting me come.”
Claire stepped aside.
Alyssa entered.
Grant closed the door.
No one offered a coat hanger. No one offered a drink.
They moved into the sitting room.
Claire took the chair by the fireplace.
Grant remained standing.
Alyssa sat on the edge of the sofa.
For several seconds, the only sound was the fire.
Claire spoke first.
“You said there were things Grant hadn’t told me.”
Alyssa looked at Grant.
“Did you tell her about the retreat?”
“Yes,” Grant said.
Claire’s gaze moved to him.
“I asked her.”
Grant stopped.
Alyssa looked back at Claire.
“Did he tell you he said he was going to leave?”
“Yes.”
“Did he tell you when?”
Claire’s fingers tightened slightly on the chair arm.
“He said he had thought about it.”
Alyssa gave a humorless smile.
“That isn’t what he told me.”
Grant’s jaw tightened.
“Alyssa.”
Claire did not look away from her.
“What did he tell you?”
Alyssa took out her phone.
Grant’s stomach dropped.
“He told me he would talk to you after the foundation gala.”
Claire looked at Grant.
He felt the room tilt.
“I said I might.”
Alyssa unlocked the phone.
“You said you would.”
Grant stepped forward.
Claire raised a hand.
He stopped.
Alyssa scrolled and held out the screen.
Claire did not take the phone.
“Read it.”
Alyssa hesitated.
Then she read.
“After Thursday, I’m done pretending this is a marriage. I’ll tell Claire when the gala is over.”
Grant closed his eyes.
He remembered sending it.
He had been in a hotel bar in New York, angry after Claire questioned why he had extended a trip by one night. He had wanted Alyssa to stop asking when he would choose.
So he had given her a deadline.
A deadline he never intended to keep.
Claire’s voice was quiet.
“When did he send that?”
“Monday.”
Three days before the gala.
Claire looked at Grant.
“You already knew you weren’t going to tell me, didn’t you?”
Grant could not lie.
“Yes.”
Alyssa looked between them.
“I thought he was leaving you.”
Claire’s mouth tightened.
“And when he didn’t?”
Alyssa looked down.
“I kept believing the next excuse.”
Grant felt anger rise.
“You knew I was married.”
Alyssa’s eyes snapped to him.
“And you knew you were married.”
The sentence hit with deserved force.
Claire leaned back.
“Why did you call me?”
Alyssa’s anger faded.
“Because he ended it and acted like I was the mistake.”
Grant started to speak.
Claire looked at him.
He stayed silent.
Alyssa continued.
“I’m not asking you to forgive me. I knew about you. I knew there were twenty-four years behind that ring. But he told me your marriage was already dead. He told me you stayed for appearances. He told me you barely spoke.”
Claire’s eyes lowered to her hands.
Alyssa swallowed.
“Then I saw you at the gala.”
Claire looked up.
“You saw what?”
“The way you looked at him before he made that joke.”
Grant’s chest tightened.
Alyssa glanced at him.
“You didn’t look like a woman in a dead marriage. You looked like a woman who still expected her husband to know better.”
The room went silent.
Claire’s face changed.
Not because Alyssa had absolved her.
Because a stranger had named the exact injury.
Grant sat down at last.
Alyssa stood.
“I brought the messages if you want them.”
Claire shook her head.
“I don’t.”
Grant looked at her.
Claire continued.
“I believe enough.”
Alyssa nodded.
At the doorway, she turned toward Grant.
“You made both of us compete with a version of the other that you invented.”
Grant said nothing.
Alyssa left.
The front door closed.
Claire remained in the chair.
Grant waited.
Finally she reached for the chain at her neck.
For one terrible second, he thought she was going to remove the ring completely.
Instead, she held it in her palm.
“You told her our marriage was dead,” Claire said.
“Yes.”
“And you told me the affair wasn’t love.”
“Yes.”
“Were either of those things true?”
Grant looked at the ring in her hand.
“No.”
Claire nodded slowly.
“That may be the worst part.”
Grant understood.
May you like
He had not lied to protect a truth.
He had lied to avoid choosing one.