Chapter 23 - Selenne’s Choice

Selenne received an offer from a documentary producer.
Five thousand dollars for an interview after release.
More if she provided copies of Thomas’s letters.
She laughed when she told Eira.
“Five thousand to sell my dead father again.”
“What are you going to do?”
“I need money.”
“That wasn’t the question.”
Selenne looked annoyed.
“I know.”
Her own release date was fourteen months away.
Eira had longer.
They had become something neither would have predicted after the common-room fight.
Not friends in the easy sense.
Something sharper.
Two people who knew exactly where the other had failed and stayed anyway.
“I spent my whole life wanting people to know what the Brookvales did to us,” Selenne said.
“Some Brookvales.”
She rolled her eyes.
“Fine. Some.”
“And now?”
“Now I know my father did things too.”
“You can say both.”
“That doesn’t make good television.”
“Then don’t make television.”
Selenne stared at her.
“You really hate cameras.”
“Recently?”
“Fair.”
Selenne declined the interview.
Instead, she authorized Lowell to provide Thomas’s relevant records to the receiver and prosecutors.
No exclusive deal.
No sensational version.
No selling the letters.
The decision cost her money.
It gave her something else.
Control.
That same week, prosecutors added a homicide-related count against Graham and Lorna.
Not first-degree murder.
The evidence did not establish premeditation beyond reasonable doubt.
They were charged under state law with felony murder and conspiracy connected to unlawful restraint and administration of a sedative during the confrontation at North Cedar, with Daniel’s death resulting from the staged carbon-monoxide exposure.
The prosecution theory was careful.
Daniel went to North Cedar voluntarily.
The argument escalated.
He was drugged to incapacitate him.
He was placed in his running car in the garage.
At some point, the plan shifted from intimidation to concealment.
Rusk was called to move the vehicle.
Whether Graham or Lorna specifically intended Daniel’s death before he lost consciousness remained disputed.
But the staging afterward was no longer seriously explainable as accident.
Eira read the charging summary twice.
It did not give her the cinematic answer people wanted.
No single villainous moment.
No confession.
No line separating fraud from murder.
Just choices.
One after another.
Then Mara arrived at Hawthorne.
The visitation room seemed smaller than before.
Mara sat behind the glass wearing a navy coat, hair shorter than Eira remembered.
For several seconds, neither sister spoke.
Finally Mara said, “You look like Dad.”
Eira almost laughed.
“That used to scare me.”
“Me too.”
Mara touched the glass.
“I’m sorry I stopped visiting.”
“I’m sorry I gave you reasons to.”
“You didn’t.”
“I did. My case wasn’t fake.”
Mara looked down.
“You were defending someone.”
“And then I kept hitting after I didn’t need to.”
Silence.
“I don’t want our family to survive by editing sentences anymore,” Eira said.
Mara nodded.
“Neither do I.”
They talked for ninety minutes.
About Daniel.
About Evelyn.
About the house.
About money.
About the mailbox.
About the years they had both spent assuming the other did not want contact.
Near the end, Mara asked, “Do you still have the photograph?”
Eira pulled it from her book.
The tape had yellowed slightly.
Mara smiled through tears.
“I remember that day.”
“Your cake melted.”
“You cried because Dad made you stand next to me.”
“I was seventeen.”
“You were unbearable.”
“So were you.”
They both laughed.
It hurt.
It healed something anyway.
As Mara stood to leave, she said, “Don’t throw that picture away.”
Eira looked at the tears Selenne had made.
“I won’t.”
Outside visitation, Selenne waited.
“How was it?”
Eira tucked the photograph safely away.
“We stopped pretending.”
Selenne nodded.
May you like
“That sounds expensive.”
“It was.”