scribe

Chapter 4

The Questions She Learned to Answer

Two years earlier, Raelan's jealousy had looked like attention.

He called during lunches because he missed her voice. He asked which colleagues would be attending the gallery dinner because he liked to plan introductions. He wanted to know when she would be home because he worried about the city at night. Each question was individually ordinary. Together they became a map of permission.

Elaris had been twenty-six when she met him at a benefit for the restoration of a public library. Raelan knew precisely how to listen in a crowded room. He asked about the reading program she had helped establish for children whose families could not afford tutoring, and he remembered her answer. He wrote the next day that her passion was refreshing among people who measured charity by the photograph it produced. Her father, who had funded the library's roof repair, regarded the young developer with immediate caution. Elaris dismissed it as an old businessman's suspicion of another ambitious man.

For a while she was happy. Raelan was attentive, amusing, well dressed, and eager to be welcomed into her world. He listened when she spoke about her mother. He brought books rather than jewelry after their second date. When she stayed late at work, he appeared with dinner and insisted she eat.

Only later did the gifts acquire terms.

The first argument concerned a male colleague who had sent Elaris a congratulatory message after a successful fund-raiser. Raelan asked why the man had used a heart emoji. She explained that the foundation's entire planning team used them. Raelan laughed, said he was teasing, and then asked again the next morning. By the end of the week, Elaris stopped replying to that colleague outside office hours to keep the peace.

The second argument concerned her father's Christmas dinner. Raelan believed Caedmon had insulted him by asking about the financing of a waterfront development. Elaris had been at the table. Her father had asked exactly what he asked every new business acquaintance: who carried the debt and who bore the risk? Raelan heard contempt. At home he accused her of failing to defend him. She apologized though she could not name what she had done wrong.

After marriage, the questions multiplied. Who was in the car with you? Why did the appointment take forty minutes longer? Why did you wear that dress to lunch? Why was your phone on silent? The answers never settled anything. New questions arrived, each claiming to be a reaction to her evasiveness.

She adapted, slowly enough to avoid recognizing it.

Once she had kept a calendar full of friends' birthdays, volunteering shifts, and little weekend excursions. Gradually the entries became fewer. A lunch canceled because Raelan disliked a colleague. A gallery opening skipped because he said the host had been disrespectful. A short trip postponed because he was anxious when she traveled alone. Each adjustment produced a calmer evening, which made the next adjustment easier. Her world did not shrink in a single locked-door moment. It narrowed by a few inches every week while everyone, including Elaris, continued calling it marriage.

Her closest friend, Clara, once said on the phone that she missed the woman who used to arrive early with three plans and an opinion about all of them. Elaris laughed and insisted pregnancy and work had made her busy. Clara did not press. She sent flowers after the call, and Elaris was genuinely touched. Yet when Raelan asked who sent them, her first impulse was not to enjoy the gift but to calculate how to explain it without inviting suspicion. Later she recognized that as one of the clearest signs of the trap: affection from someone else had begun to feel like a problem she needed to manage. She sent photographs of restaurant tables to prove she was alone. She shared her location. She canceled a weekend with friends because Raelan accused her of preferring their company. She learned that a neutral expression could be called cold and a warm one flirtatious. She made herself careful until careful felt like personality.

The pregnancy had brought a brief truce. When the test came back positive, Raelan kissed her forehead and cried. For three days he talked about names, houses, and being different from his own father. Then came the questions again, now wrapped in concern for the baby. Why did she need to go anywhere without him? Why was she working when stress might be harmful? Why did she wear a fitted dress that showed her body? Elaris began to feel she was shrinking inside a life that everyone congratulated her for building.

The salon appointment was her first unscheduled hour in nearly a month. She had chosen it because she wanted to feel beautiful without asking permission. The decision was so small she had been ashamed to think of it as freedom.

In Caedmon's townhouse, the next morning, she stood before the bathroom mirror and studied the faint discoloration at her cheek. She could remember every question Raelan asked that day. She could not remember the last question she had asked herself.

Her phone held another message from him: We can fix this if you'll just be honest about where your head has been.

For several seconds she almost wrote the long explanation that her fingers knew by habit. Instead she opened a blank note and typed a different question.

May you like

What do I need to feel safe?

She looked at the words, uncomfortable in their simplicity. Then she began a list of answers that did not include Raelan's approval.

Related Stories

Other posts