scribe

Chapter 2 - THE FIRST LIE

Lucien Vale had the kind of face that made strangers assume certainty.

At forty-two, he was broad-shouldered, controlled, and accustomed to rooms changing when he entered them. He managed a family investment company, sat on two charitable boards, and had spent most of his adult life making decisions other people trusted.

But grief had left one permanent weakness in him.

He wanted peace badly enough to mistake silence for it.

“What happened?” he asked again.

Maristelle took one step toward him.

“Sir, I heard Aveline crying from the service corridor. She was inside that suitcase. The lid was closed. Mrs. Vale was pulling it across the foyer.”

Lucien’s gaze dropped to the suitcase.

Vespera gave a soft, incredulous laugh.

“That makes it sound monstrous.”

“It was monstrous.”

“Maristelle.” Lucien’s voice sharpened.

Aveline flinched.

He saw it and immediately lowered his tone.

“Give her to me.”

The toddler hesitated when he reached out.

That hesitation hurt him visibly.

“Ave,” he said gently. “Papa.”

She finally leaned toward him, but one hand remained tangled in Maristelle’s apron until the last possible second.

Lucien carried her to the bench beneath the staircase and sat with her on his knee.

“Did you get hurt?”

Aveline stared at the floor.

Vespera crouched beside them.

“She climbed inside while I was sorting things for storage,” she said. “I closed the lid for one moment because she kept laughing and popping up. Then I moved the case two feet. She became frightened. I stopped immediately.”

Maristelle stared.

“That is not what happened.”

Vespera looked wounded now.

“Then perhaps you should tell Lucien what you think happened.”

“I think you put her inside on purpose.”

“Why would I do that?”

Maristelle’s answer came without hesitation.

“Because you resent her.”

The foyer became still.

Lucien closed his eyes for half a second.

“Enough.”

Vespera stood slowly.

“There it is,” she whispered.

Maristelle looked at Lucien. “Sir, you need to check the cameras.”

That changed something.

Vespera’s hand moved almost imperceptibly toward the console table, where her phone lay beside a silver bowl.

Lucien noticed neither gesture nor tension.

“The foyer cameras have been offline all week,” he said. “The security company is replacing a control unit.”

Maristelle turned toward Vespera.

Vespera did not smile.

She did not need to.

“A coincidence?” Maristelle asked.

Lucien rose.

“Maristelle.”

“What?”

“You are upset. I understand that.”

“You shouldn’t understand me. You should understand her.” She pointed to Aveline.

The child had gone very quiet.

Vespera folded her arms.

“This is exactly what I mean. Every difficulty becomes an accusation. If I correct Aveline, Maristelle thinks I’m cruel. If I carry her upstairs, I’m ‘too rough.’ If she cries when I leave the nursery, somehow I caused it.”

Lucien looked at Maristelle.

“How long have you felt this way?”

“Months.”

“And you never came to me?”

“I tried.”

Vespera turned sharply. “When?”

“The morning after the winter charity dinner. I told him Aveline was afraid to eat breakfast until someone said she could.”

Lucien frowned.

He remembered the conversation, but only vaguely. He had been reading emails at the time. Maristelle had said something about Aveline becoming timid.

He had answered without looking up.

She’s two. Two-year-olds are strange about food.

He felt the memory with sudden discomfort.

Vespera placed a hand on his sleeve.

“Lucien, she has been grieving Celia for years. We all know that. But lately it’s becoming unhealthy.”

Maristelle went still.

There was the real attack.

Not liar.

Not insubordinate.

Unstable.

Lucien looked tired rather than convinced.

“Maristelle, take the evening off.”

“No.”

His eyebrows rose.

“I’m not leaving Aveline.”

“This is my house.”

“And she is your daughter.”

Vespera inhaled softly.

Lucien’s face hardened.

“Go home. We will discuss this tomorrow.”

Maristelle understood the order.

She also understood the fear in Aveline’s eyes when Vespera reached for her.

The toddler twisted away.

“No Ves.”

Two words.

Lucien froze.

Vespera froze too.

Aveline reached toward Maristelle.

“Mari home.”

Maristelle did not move.

Lucien looked down at his daughter for a long moment.

Then he said quietly, “Maristelle stays tonight.”

Vespera’s hand fell from his sleeve.

And for the first time since Lucien entered the foyer, the mask slipped.

Only for a second.

May you like

But Maristelle saw it.

So did Lucien.

Related Stories

Other posts