Chapter 5 - The Third Peg

The second anonymous note came hidden inside Marisol's prayer book the next morning.
This time the handwriting was different - thin, slanted, almost certainly written with the opposite hand.
NORTH TACK ROOM. THIRD PEG. BEFORE DUSK.
Anna stared at it.
"Someone is playing with us."
"Yes," Marisol said. "The question is whether they want me frightened or informed."
The north tack room had not been used for years. A storm had damaged part of its roof, and the newer stable wing made it unnecessary. Dust covered the door hinges. The lock had rusted open.
Marisol and Anna waited until the household gathered for afternoon tea.
Inside, broken saddle trees leaned against walls. Mouse droppings scattered the floor. Three rows of wooden pegs held old bridles beneath sheets of cobweb.
"Third peg," Anna whispered.
Nothing hung from it.
Marisol ran her hand along the wood.
The peg moved.
Behind it was a narrow recess cut into the wall.
Inside lay a small ledger wrapped in oilcloth.
Anna crossed herself.
Marisol opened the cover.
The book belonged to the stable, not the estate office. Feed purchases. Farrier charges. Horse assignments. Most entries were in Elias Webb's careful hand.
But the final pages contained a second set of notes in newer ink.
Oct. 3 - Lady M requested gentle mare Clover. Mrs. H instructed Rowan instead.
Oct. 3 - Rowan given extra grain at noon by order from house.
Oct. 3 - old saddle no. 7 removed from retirement rack by J. Pike.
Marisol's mouth went dry.
The date was the day of the riding lesson.
"Mrs. H," Anna said. "Harcourt."
"Prudence."
Marisol turned the page.
Several older entries caught her eye.
Sept. 19 - Mrs. H asked whether Lady M still walks east terrace alone.
Sept. 27 - Mr. Hale's carriage 12:40 a.m.
Sept. 29 - two surveyors through stable gate. Told not to record in main visitor book.
Anna leaned closer.
"Who wrote these?"
The letters were not Elias's.
Marisol recognized them anyway.
A young groom named Daniel Pike kept feed counts in the kitchen yard every Monday. She had seen his narrow hand on tally slips.
"Daniel."
Marisol spent the next hour copying every page in Daniel's ledger by hand. Anna read the entries aloud while Marisol wrote, because if the original disappeared they would still possess something. The process made the plot feel colder. Each line was ordinary by itself: a horse assignment, a feed order, a carriage arrival. Only when placed together did intent emerge.
"This is how they did it," Marisol said.
"Did what?"
"Made everything look too small to object to."
Anna considered that. "A different horse is small. Extra oats are small. An old saddle is small."
"Until all three happen to the same woman on the same afternoon."
Marisol wrapped the copy in plain cloth and gave it to Anna.
"Do not keep it in my room."
"Where then?"
"With someone Prudence does not think matters."
Anna chose Mrs. Greer, the laundress, who was sixty-three, nearly invisible to the upper household, and known to hide coins in hems for servants saving to marry. Mrs. Greer accepted the packet without asking its contents and stitched it inside a stack of old altar linens awaiting repair.
The decision mattered later, though none of them knew it then. Prudence was accustomed to controlling important people. She had never learned to count the quiet ones.
A floorboard creaked outside.
Anna blew out the small lantern.
They stood motionless in darkness.
The door opened.
Light cut across the floor.
Someone entered.
Marisol heard breathing.
Then the scrape of a shoe near the wall.
A hand touched the third peg.
Found the recess empty.
The person whispered a curse.
Anna's fingers closed around Marisol's wrist.
The intruder stepped farther inside.
Marisol could see only a silhouette, slender and upright.
Prudence.
The figure turned toward the storage alcove where the women hid.
Then another voice called from outside.
"Mrs. Harcourt? Lord Vale is asking for you."
Prudence froze.
"Tell him I am coming."
Her voice.
No doubt.
She left.
Marisol waited until the footsteps faded, then exhaled.
Anna's face was white.
"She knew the ledger existed."
"And she expected it to still be here."
Marisol wrapped the book again.
On the final page, beneath the October entries, Daniel had written one line that neither woman had seen at first.
If anything happens to me, ask Master Webb about the black account book.
Marisol looked at Anna.
"Where is Daniel Pike?"
Anna swallowed.
"He was dismissed this morning."
"For what?"
"Stealing oats."
Marisol looked down at the ledger.
A man who stole oats did not usually keep records proving someone else ordered them.
"Find out where he went," she said.
At that moment, the stable bell rang once.
May you like
Then twice.
Then a third time - the signal that a horse had returned without its rider.