Chapter 3 - The Call

Celestine answered the school’s call without taking her eyes off Vinnie.
“Mrs. Ashcroft?” said Ms. Bellamy’s polished voice. “I hope I’m not interrupting dinner.”
“Not at all.”
Vinnie backed away from the island.
“I wanted to mention that Lavinia has seemed unusually sensitive this week.”
Celestine’s hand tightened around the phone.
“In what way?”
“Some tears. A little forgetfulness. She misplaced her lunch money several times.”
Celestine watched Vinnie’s expression.
Bellamy continued, “I thought you should know before it becomes a habit.”
“That’s interesting.”
A pause.
“Interesting?”
“Vinnie just told me she didn’t eat lunch today.”
Bellamy’s response came half a beat late. “Children can be selective.”
“She had crackers from another student.”
“Well, I can’t supervise every bite.”
“Of course.”
Celestine’s calmness was deliberate. She had learned long ago that frightened people often revealed more when they thought you believed them.
Bellamy exhaled sympathetically. “Lavinia is a lovely child. But she can be imaginative when she feels embarrassed.”
Vinnie’s eyes filled again.
Celestine said, “Thank you for calling.”
After she hung up, she found Vinnie in the hallway.
“Did she tell you I lied?” Vinnie asked.
“She suggested you might.”
Vinnie looked defeated rather than surprised.
Celestine crouched so they were eye level. “I need you to hear something. You are not in trouble.”
“But if I tell you—”
“Whatever happens afterward is my responsibility, not yours.”
Vinnie’s lips trembled.
“She makes me buy her lunch.”
Celestine did not react outwardly.
“How many times?”
“Four.”
“Using your money?”
A nod.
“And today?”
“She told me to do it again. I said I couldn’t.”
Vinnie touched her shoulder unconsciously.
Celestine noticed.
“What happened?”
“Nothing.”
“Vinnie.”
“She pushed me.”
Celestine’s face went still.
Vinnie rushed to explain. “Not really hard. I didn’t fall. She was angry.”
“That does not make it acceptable.”
“She said people would think I was trying to get her in trouble.”
Celestine stood.
For a moment she wanted to call the head of school immediately. She wanted Bellamy confronted before another minute passed.
Then she remembered the phone call.
Bellamy had called first.
She had begun constructing a version of events before Vinnie spoke.
That meant she understood there was something to hide.
Celestine returned to the kitchen and opened the school’s parent portal. Lunch purchases at Westchester Academy were processed through student accounts unless cash was used at the small faculty café counter.
Vinnie had always used cash because she liked counting her own change.
“Do you have receipts?”
Vinnie shook her head. “Ms. Bellamy kept them.”
“Every time?”
“Yes.”
Celestine thought of Bellamy’s desk.
“Did anyone see you buy the food?”
“The café lady.”
“Anyone else?”
“Sometimes.”
Celestine closed the laptop.
“Tomorrow you are not giving Ms. Bellamy one dollar.”
Fear flashed across Vinnie’s face.
“She’ll be angry.”
“I know.”
“What if she says I’m lying?”
Celestine took her daughter’s hands.
“Then we won’t argue with her memory.”
May you like
Vinnie blinked.
“We’ll find evidence.”