scribe

Chapter 10 - The Price of Consistency

Outside counsel moved quickly.

By Monday, Rebecca Sloan had hired a forensic accountant and advised Natalie to stop accessing financial systems personally so no one could later accuse her of altering records.

The first findings were worse than expected.

Northstar had received $1.9 million from four donor-supported programs across three private schools. Blackthorne represented the largest share. The company had no physical office, no licensed tutoring staff under its own name, and no payroll records consistent with the services billed.

Most of the money moved within days of receipt.

Some went to a consulting firm owned by Melissa Keene.

Some went to a property company connected to Dr. Keene.

And $186,000 had been transferred over two years to a private management company called VH Strategic Services.

Victor Harrington was its sole owner.

Natalie read the report in Rebecca’s office with her hands clasped tightly enough to hurt.

“Could there be a legitimate explanation?” she asked.

“Victor may claim consulting fees,” Rebecca said. “But he never disclosed them to the foundation board. That alone is a serious conflict.”

Natalie stared at the number.

$186,000.

Not enough to explain a grand criminal empire.

Enough to explain compromise.

Enough to buy silence one decision at a time.

When Natalie confronted Victor that evening, he did not deny the company existed.

“I advised Blackthorne on donor strategy,” he said.

“Through a vendor we were funding?”

“I didn’t set it up that way.”

“You signed the payments.”

“I signed foundation grants. Keene chose subcontractors.”

“And then his subcontractor paid you.”

Victor slammed his hand on the kitchen island. “I was trying to keep the foundation solvent after Dad died!”

Natalie stared at him.

The truth had cracked open.

Victor paced, breathing hard. “Dad left commitments everywhere. Scholarship promises. Building pledges. Endowments that were underfunded because the market dropped. You got to be the moral chairperson while I had to make numbers work.”

“So you took money.”

“I took consulting fees.”

“You hid them.”

“Because you would have reacted exactly like this.”

Natalie’s voice fell. “Did you know Keene was falsifying student records?”

Victor stopped pacing.

That pause told her more than his answer.

“I knew the participation numbers were… flexible.”

“Flexible?”

“I thought they were counting students who had occasional support.”

“Evie had none.”

“I didn’t know they used her.”

“Would it have mattered if it were someone else’s child?”

Victor’s face crumpled for a second, then hardened again.

“You’re going to destroy everything Dad built.”

Natalie shook her head.

“No, Victor. You keep calling the wreckage a legacy.”

Behind them, a floorboard creaked.

Evie stood at the hallway entrance.

She had heard everything.

The forensic accountant, Samuel Ortega, explained the transaction pattern without drama. “Fraud usually survives because each individual step can be described as something ordinary. A consulting fee. A subcontractor. A reclassification. A rushed approval. What matters is the pattern.”

Natalie looked at the lines of payments and thought of the test. Four altered bubbles had looked ordinary until compared with the calculations beneath them.

Victor’s $186,000 had arrived in eighteen separate transfers. No single payment exceeded $15,000. Several coincided with grant renewals or moments when foundation staff had asked questions about Northstar. Samuel did not call them bribes. He simply marked the dates.

“Intent is for investigators and counsel,” he said. “My job is to show movement.”

That restraint made the evidence feel stronger.

When Evie overheard the argument, she ran upstairs before Natalie could stop her. Natalie found her kneeling beside the bed, pushing school papers into a trash bag.

“What are you doing?”

“I don’t want any of it.”

Natalie took the bag gently. “You don’t have to decide tonight.”

“What if my good grades are fake too?”

“They aren’t.”

“How do you know?”

Because I trust you, Natalie almost said. But after everything, she understood Evie needed more than comfort.

“Because we have the original tutoring work. Because Mr. Jonah watched you solve problems. Because your process matches your answers. And because nobody gets to take real work away from you just because they corrupted other records.”

May you like

Evie loosened her grip on the bag.

Evidence, Natalie realized, could heal as well as accuse.

Related Stories

Other posts