scribe

Chapter 12 - No Perfect Villain

Bella had expected to feel happy when she learned Evan Monroe had not stolen the equipment. Instead, she felt cheated.

If he had been guilty, then Cece would have been wrong in a neat, dramatic way. Her family would have accused Bella’s father while hiding a criminal in their own house. The world would have balanced itself.

But Evan had not stolen anything.

He had simply been frightened enough to let suspicion fall elsewhere.

At breakfast, Bella pushed blueberries around her plate.

“That’s worse,” she decided.

Michael raised an eyebrow. “Worse than theft?”

“No. Worse for the story.”

Laura almost smiled.

Bella continued. “If Mr. Monroe didn’t do it, then Cece can say her family was innocent too.”

“Her father may be innocent of theft,” Michael said. “That doesn’t erase everything else.”

“But then nobody gets punished.”

Michael looked at her carefully. “Is punishment what you want?”

Bella opened her mouth and stopped.

She imagined Cece alone in the hallway, red-eyed, asking if Michael was mad at her.

“I want it to matter,” Bella said.

“That’s different.”

At school, Principal Nolan announced new anti-bullying procedures without naming Bella or Cece. Students would receive instruction on rumor, digital gossip, and harassment. Faculty would document repeated social targeting rather than treating each incident in isolation.

Ms. Vale also removed the ruler from her desk.

Bella noticed immediately.

“Where did it go?” she asked after class.

“In a drawer at home.”

“Because of me?”

“Because of me,” Ms. Vale replied.

Bella nodded.

Cece hovered near the classroom door.

“Can I talk to Bella?” she asked.

Ms. Vale looked at Bella.

Bella shrugged.

Cece approached slowly. “My dad didn’t steal anything.”

“I know.”

Cece’s eyes widened. “How?”

“My dad told me.”

Cece looked relieved, then guilty for looking relieved.

“They said someone stole his login.”

“I know that too.”

“My mom says everything got out of control.”

Bella’s expression hardened. “Things don’t just get out of control by themselves.”

Cece stared at her shoes.

“My dad said something similar.”

“What did he say?”

“That he kept quiet because he was scared, and being scared doesn’t make silence harmless.”

Bella absorbed that.

Cece looked up. “I’m sorry.”

This time, there was no explanation after the words. No “but.” No mention of the class election.

Bella felt the difference.

“I’m still mad at you,” she said.

“I know.”

“I don’t want to be your friend right now.”

Cece nodded. “Okay.”

“But I won’t tell people your dad is a thief.”

Cece’s face twisted with shame.

“I know.”

May you like

As she walked away, Bella realized that refusing to repeat the same cruelty did not feel like losing.

It felt like choosing who she wanted to become.

Related Stories

Other posts