scribe

Chapter 5 - The Other Test

Claire retained an education attorney named Rachel Voss.

Rachel was practical, unsentimental, and visibly unimpressed by prestige.

She listened to the school’s version, reviewed Cece’s altered academic records, and studied Edward’s letter.

Then she said, “Do not send Cece back into Collins’s classroom.”

The school placed Ms. Collins on temporary administrative leave pending investigation of the slap.

Headmaster Bell described the action as “precautionary.”

Rachel called it “damage containment.”

They requested the identity of the student whose test matched Cece’s.

The school refused.

Rachel filed a formal preservation demand for video, electronic grade logs, test scans, email records, and document access history.

That afternoon, Bell called Claire personally.

“You’re escalating very quickly.”

Claire stood at her kitchen window.

“My daughter’s face escalated quickly too.”

“I’m trying to protect all students involved.”

“Then preserve the evidence.”

A pause.

“It is being preserved.”

Rachel, listening on speakerphone, wrote one word on a legal pad:

Maybe.

Two days later, the school produced a scanned copy of the second test with the name redacted.

Rachel enlarged the scan.

Cece sat beside them.

“That’s not the paper I saw,” she said.

Rachel turned. “What do you mean?”

“The one on Ms. Collins’s desk had a yellow corner.”

The scan was clean white.

Claire looked closer.

Cece pointed to question eight.

“And this line was bent.”

Rachel asked, “Are you sure?”

Cece nodded.

“I watched her slam them down.”

Rachel requested the original.

Bell replied that the original had been misplaced during administrative review.

“Misplaced,” Claire repeated.

Rachel’s expression hardened. “That is a very expensive word.”

They turned to the classroom video.

The footage showed Ms. Collins confronting Cece.

It showed the slap.

It showed students reacting.

But the camera angle did not capture the desktop clearly enough to identify the second paper.

Then Rachel slowed the footage.

At 1:42 p.m., sixteen minutes before the accusation, Headmaster Bell entered the room while students were at recess.

He carried a red file folder.

Ms. Collins took something from it.

Bell left.

Cece returned two minutes later to retrieve a scarf from her chair.

That was when she had seen him.

Rachel froze the frame.

“Can we see what’s in the folder?”

“No.”

Claire stared at Bell’s hand.

A small brass key ring hung from one finger.

Cece leaned toward the screen.

“That’s Grandpa Edward’s key.”

Nathaniel, who had just entered the room, stopped.

“What?”

Cece pointed.

“The little lion.”

The Whitmore family crest featured a lion.

Nathaniel zoomed in.

The key fob carried the same crest.

Claire slowly turned toward him.

“How did Headmaster Bell get a Whitmore archive key?”

Nathaniel said nothing.

Rachel looked between them.

“Mr. Whitmore?”

Finally he spoke.

“There were only four.”

“Who had them?”

“My father. Me. Julian.”

“And the fourth?”

Nathaniel’s face tightened.

“My mother.”

May you like

Evelyn Whitmore was still alive.

And she lived fifteen minutes away.

Related Stories

Other posts