Chapter 4 - WHAT LILY ALREADY KNEW
Lily came home from her part-time job at the bookstore carrying a paper bag of muffins and wearing the look she used when she wanted to ask a question without being the first person to speak. She had inherited that expression from Daniel. For a moment I hated the resemblance, then hated myself for noticing it.
"You went to see Dad," she said.
"Yes."
She put the muffins on the counter. "Is he in the hospital again?"
The word again made me turn. "What do you mean, again?"
Lily stared at me. The silence lasted long enough for the refrigerator motor to start and stop. "He made me promise not to tell you."
I gripped the back of a chair. "Tell me what?"
"I saw an oxygen machine at his place last winter. He said he had a lung condition. I asked if he was dying. He told me he didn't know."
I closed my eyes. My daughter had carried that fear through college applications and final exams while I congratulated myself on keeping the divorce from taking over her life.
"You shouldn't have had to keep his secret," I said.
"He looked scared. And he said you would worry."
"I would have worried. That's what mothers do when somebody they love is sick."
Lily's eyes filled. "You still love him?"
The question had no simple answer. "I care what happens to him. Loving somebody doesn't undo what they did."
She sat at the table. "He told me he had an affair. Everyone told me he had an affair. Then he said I shouldn't tell you about his breathing. How many versions of Dad am I supposed to believe?"
I sat beside her and explained what he had confessed. I didn't soften the lie into a romantic sacrifice. I told her he had been frightened, that he had made a choice for us without asking, and that his illness did not make that choice fair.
Lily covered her mouth. "So our whole family broke up because he was sick?"
"Our family changed because he lied. The sickness was real. So was his responsibility for what happened next."
"I should have told you."
"No. An adult asked you to carry something too heavy. You didn't fail me."
She cried then, with the sudden violence of someone who had spent months holding her breath. I held her without telling her everything would be fine. That would have been another lie.
Noah came downstairs as we were wiping our faces. He saw us and stopped on the last step. "Is somebody dead?"
"No," I said. "But Dad is very ill, and we need to talk."
He came to the table wearing mismatched socks. I explained the illness first. I told him the doctors were concerned about Daniel's breathing and that we were going to visit together. Then I explained the false confession.
Noah listened with his hands under the table. "So he didn't like another woman better than us?"
"No, sweetheart."
"Did he think we couldn't handle a sick dad?"
"I think he was afraid of being seen sick. That was his fear, not a measure of what you could handle."
Noah considered this. "I was sick last year. He came over and brought soup. He didn't make me move to another house."
Lily and I both looked at him. The simplicity of what he said was devastating.
"You're right," I answered.
That night Lily sat on the edge of my bed after Noah had gone upstairs. She said she remembered being thirteen and hearing our arguments through the bedroom wall. She used to count how many seconds passed between voices because she thought a long silence meant one of us had decided to leave. I told her the adults had been responsible for making her feel safe, and that we had failed her in different ways. She asked whether she could be angry at both of us. I said yes. The relief on her face made me realize how often children ask permission to feel what they already feel. I told her about the day I found a brochure for a seaside trip in Daniel's coat pocket just before the confession. For years I thought it proved he was planning a holiday with his lover. I had thrown it out before he could explain. Now I wondered whether it was one of the places he considered visiting while he could still travel comfortably. Lily asked if I regretted throwing it away. I said I regretted the circumstances that made a simple brochure feel like evidence in a trial. She nodded.
The following afternoon we visited Daniel together. A nurse helped him sit up. His oxygen tubing curved beneath his nose, and he looked surprised by the force of our arrival.
Lily spoke first. "I know everything."
Daniel's expression collapsed. "I'm sorry."
"You made me keep a secret from Mom."
"I did. I shouldn't have."
Noah approached the bed. "Were you going to tell us before you died?"
"I was trying to tell you now."
"That's not the same."
"No," Daniel said. "It isn't."
They asked questions for nearly an hour. Some were medical. Some were about divorce. Some couldn't be answered. Daniel did not pretend otherwise. When Noah asked whether his father would be alive for his next birthday, Daniel said, "I hope so. But I can't promise."
It was the first time I had heard him give our son uncertainty instead of a comforting story.
On the way home, Lily leaned against the car window. Noah asked whether we could stop for fries. We did. We sat in the parking lot eating from a paper bag, the three of us trying to understand how a family could keep functioning when its history had changed overnight.
Finally Lily said, "I'm still mad at him."
"Me too," I answered.
May you like
Noah held up a fry. "Can we love him anyway?"
I looked at my children in the fading light. "Yes," I said. "We can."