Chapter 23 - The Letter Maelys Did Not Send

A year after the lake incident, Maelys asked to read Leonora’s letter again.
The one that began: I frightened you on purpose.
Vivienne retrieved it from the drawer where it had remained untouched.
“Do you want me here?” she asked.
“Yes. But don’t read over my shoulder.”
“I can manage that.”
Maelys read the entire letter slowly.
Leonora wrote about fear of poverty, shame, ambition, and the belief that if she controlled enough money no one could ever make her feel powerless again.
She wrote that Nathaniel had loved her generosity at first, not realizing how much of it came from needing admiration.
She wrote that she resented his willingness to preserve land instead of maximizing its value.
She wrote that Quentin recognized her fear and made it sound practical.
Then she wrote:
None of those things made me lock the door. I did that. I chose a punishment designed to make you afraid I would abandon you. I knew you feared losing another parent. I used that fear. There is no version of that choice in which I was protecting you.
Maelys stopped.
That sentence hurt.
It also helped.
Because it named the ugliest part without asking Maelys to rename it.
She finished the letter.
Then she took out a blank sheet of paper.
Vivienne said nothing.
Maelys wrote for almost an hour.
Dear Leonora,
I used to think I wanted you to explain everything. Now I think explanations are like maps. They can show how somebody got somewhere, but they do not make the place good.
I believe you were scared of not having money. I believe Uncle Quentin helped you make bad things sound reasonable. I believe you loved some things about me.
I also believe you used me.
I am not ready to see you.
I do not know if I ever will be.
I do not hate you every day anymore. Sometimes I do not think about you at all. I think that might be the best thing that has happened.
I kept half of the burgundy ribbon Grandma gave me. I thought the lake ruined it, but it didn’t. The ribbon was there before that morning and it still exists after it.
I think I am like that too.
Maelys put down her pencil.
“Do you want to send it?” Vivienne asked.
“No.”
“Okay.”
“Is that mean?”
“No.”
“Even if she would want it?”
“Yes.”
Maelys folded the letter and placed it inside the chess box with the black knight and half the ribbon.
“Then why did I write it?”
Vivienne smiled faintly.
“Maybe because some words are for the person writing them.”
That summer, Maelys spent more time at Bellweather.
She learned to row Northstar under supervision. She helped a biologist count nesting loons. She complained about mosquitoes, fell in the water twice, and discovered she hated blueberry pancakes despite having claimed for years to love them because Nathaniel loved them.
The first time she admitted that, Vivienne stared at her dramatically.
“Who are you and what have you done with my niece?”
Maelys laughed.
“I hate blueberries.”
“Your father will haunt us.”
“He said I could ask questions. He didn’t say I had to eat bad fruit.”
Little by little, preferences appeared where obedience had been.
She disliked wool socks.
She preferred mystery books to fantasy.
She loved rowing but hated sailing.
She wanted her hair loose more often.
She did not want to call every adult by a title.
She liked being asked.
At the end of summer, Elias brought her the annual trust summary.
It showed restitution received, investment balances, conservation income, lodge expenses, and legal fees.
“Do I have to understand all of this?” Maelys asked.
“No.”
“Will you explain it if I ask?”
“Yes.”
“What if I ask the same thing five times?”
“Then I will discover whether I am truly a fiduciary or merely a man with a cane and opinions.”
May you like
Maelys grinned.
She asked six times.