Chapter 4 - PLENTY

Wesley had five dress shirts.
That was technically true.
One was the old white shirt with the missing button.
One was a pale-green shirt from two Christmases ago that pulled tight across his shoulders.
One was a checked shirt with a bleach mark near the hem.
One belonged to his school uniform and had the school crest stitched over the chest.
And one was the slate-blue Oxford shirt currently hanging in the guest-room closet because Allison had told Hudson it was his now.
Plenty depended on how you counted.
Wesley sat on the edge of his bed with the button packet in one hand.
Hudson stood near the door.
“You can have the blue shirt back,” Hudson said.
Wesley looked up.
“You don’t have to.”
“I don’t want it if it’s yours.”
Wesley turned the packet over between his fingers.
The button inside made a tiny plastic tick.
“It’s not your fault.”
Hudson’s shoulders lowered a little.
“Are you gonna tell?”
“Tell what?”
“That I took this.”
Wesley thought about it.
“Will you get in trouble?”
“Probably.”
“Then no.”
Hudson frowned. “But it was wrong.”
Wesley gave him the smallest smile.
“You’re seven.”
Hudson looked offended. “That doesn’t mean I can steal.”
Wesley almost laughed.
Instead, he opened the packet.
“I’m going to sew it on.”
“You know how?”
“Kind of.”
Their grandmother had shown him once how to thread a needle when he tore a pillow seam at her house.
He found Allison’s small hotel sewing kit in the dressing-area drawer and carried it back to his room before anyone noticed.
Hudson sat cross-legged on the floor while Wesley threaded white cotton through a needle.
His first attempt missed the buttonhole entirely.
His second made a loose loop.
On the third, the needle pricked his fingertip.
“Ow.”
Hudson leaned forward. “You bleeding?”
“Barely.”
“Do we need a Band-Aid?”
“No.”
“You sure?”
Wesley looked at him.
Hudson was always asking if things needed fixing.
That was not what Wesley had expected from the cousin who got his shirt.
They finished the button together.
It sat slightly crooked.
Wesley buttoned the old shirt and looked in the mirror.
The cuffs were still too short.
But the front stayed closed.
“Looks good,” Hudson said.
“It looks crooked.”
“Good crooked.”
“There’s no such thing.”
Hudson shrugged. “There is now.”
A knock sounded at the door.
Allison stepped in before either boy answered.
“There you are. Hudson, your mom’s ten minutes away.”
Then she saw Wesley wearing the white shirt.
Her eyes moved to the newly attached button.
“You found it?”
Wesley looked at Hudson.
Hudson stared at his socks.
“Yes.”
“Where?”
“Under some stuff.”
Allison nodded as if that settled the matter.
“See? I told you it wasn’t lost.”
Wesley felt something strange happen inside him.
It was not anger exactly.
Anger was hot.
This was colder.
His mother had not told him it wasn’t lost. She had searched and failed to find it. She had been ready to buy another one sometime. Now, because the button had appeared, the story had changed into one where she had been right all along.
He looked down at the crooked stitches.
“I sewed it.”
Allison smiled. “Look at you. Independent.”
Independent.
The word should have felt like praise.
Instead, it landed strangely.
Hudson looked up sharply.
Wesley began unbuttoning the shirt.
“Can I have the blue one back?” he asked.
Allison’s smile faded.
“We already told Hudson he could keep it.”
“You told him.”
Her eyes narrowed slightly. “What does that mean?”
Wesley kept his voice steady.
“I thought he was borrowing it because his got wet.”
“Well, I decided he could keep it. He needs something nice for church anyway.”
Hudson stood.
“I don’t need it.”
Allison turned to him. “Honey, it’s fine.”
“I can give it back.”
“No. I said it’s fine.”
Matthew appeared in the hall, drawn by the voices.
“What’s happening?”
Allison folded her arms.
“Nothing. Wesley is upset about the shirt again.”
Again.
Wesley looked at his father.
Matthew rubbed one hand over his beard.
“Buddy, I understand you liked it.”
“It was mine.”
“Yes, but Hudson needs—”
“He has clothes.”
Hudson flinched.
Wesley saw it and immediately regretted how the sentence sounded.
“I mean—”
Matthew cut in. “And this is exactly why your mother was trying to be generous without making it a big thing.”
Wesley stared at him.
“Generous with whose shirt?”
The words came out before he could stop them.
The room went silent.
Allison’s face hardened.
Matthew lowered his voice.
“Watch your tone.”
Wesley’s eyes went to the carpet.
“Yes, sir.”
Hudson stepped closer to Allison.
“Aunt Allison, I really don’t want it.”
She looked down at him.
“You’re not giving it back because you feel guilty. Wesley has plenty.”
There it was again.
Plenty.
Wesley looked around his room.
His bookshelf held secondhand paperbacks from school sales. His sneakers by the closet had been scrubbed clean for fall. His desk chair had one loose wheel that Matthew kept promising to tighten.
He did have plenty.
He knew children at school who had less.
He knew being upset about a shirt could sound spoiled.
That was the problem with plenty.
It could be used to prove you were not allowed to notice when something of yours disappeared.
A horn sounded outside.
Hudson’s mother had arrived.
Allison clapped her hands once. “Okay. Bag. Shoes. Let’s go.”
Hudson did not move.
He looked at Wesley.
Then at Allison.
“Can I leave the shirt here?”
Allison sighed.
“Hudson.”
He took a breath.
“It doesn’t fit me right.”
Everyone in the room knew that was not true.
But Hudson had found the only reason he thought adults might accept.
Wesley looked at him with new understanding.
His cousin was learning the same thing he had learned.
May you like
Sometimes the truth itself was not enough.
You had to give adults a reason they found convenient.