scribe

Chapter 12 - The Question He Could Not Answer

Dr. Nia Barrett did not let Thaddeus hide inside the accident.

He disliked her for that during their first three sessions.

She was a rehabilitation psychologist, calm without being soft, and remarkably skilled at allowing silence to become uncomfortable enough that people filled it honestly.

Thaddeus first saw her because his treatment team recommended support for adjustment, pain, and anxiety.

He intended to discuss all three.

Instead, by the fourth session, they were talking about Celia.

"My wife filed for divorce," he said.

Dr. Barrett nodded.

"How do you feel?"

"Like my wife filed for divorce while I'm trying to recover from a major accident."

"That tells me what happened, not how you feel."

Thaddeus stared at her.

"Angry."

"What else?"

"Scared."

"What else?"

He looked toward the window.

"Humiliated."

"Why humiliated?"

"Because everybody knows. My brother knows. My friends know. The staff here knows I'm married but my wife doesn't visit."

Dr. Barrett leaned back slightly.

"What story do you imagine they tell themselves?"

"That she abandoned me."

"Did she?"

Thaddeus's jaw tightened.

"I left first."

"Why?"

"I had an affair."

"And then?"

"I moved in with the other woman."

"And now?"

"She's gone too."

Dr. Barrett's expression remained neutral.

Thaddeus hated neutrality. It gave him nothing to push against.

"You think I'm a terrible person."

"I haven't told you what I think."

"You don't have to."

"Interesting."

He frowned.

"What's interesting?"

"You appear very concerned with whether other people think you are a bad person."

"Wouldn't you be?"

"Perhaps. But I might also ask why that question matters more than whether I caused harm."

Thaddeus looked away.

He thought about Celia saying she had been expected to protect how he saw himself.

Dr. Barrett continued.

"What do you want from your wife?"

"My marriage."

"That's a structure. What do you want from her?"

"I want her to come back."

"That's an action. Why?"

Thaddeus exhaled impatiently.

"Because I love her."

"That's a feeling."

"What answer are you looking for?"

"Yours."

He stared at her.

Finally he said, "I want her with me."

"Why?"

"Because she knows me."

Dr. Barrett waited.

"Because she knows what I need before I ask. Because she doesn't panic in a crisis. Because she understands my family. Because I trust her."

The last words stopped him.

Dr. Barrett did not rescue him from the contradiction.

Thaddeus swallowed.

"I know how that sounds."

"How does it sound?"

"Like I wanted trust from someone I didn't give trust to."

The room became quiet.

Dr. Barrett asked, "What do you want to give Celia?"

Thaddeus opened his mouth.

Nothing came.

He thought of answers that would sound good.

Love.

Security.

An apology.

A future.

But those were abstract.

What did Celia actually need from him now?

Space, perhaps.

Honesty.

Accountability.

Freedom from his expectations.

None of those things helped him get her back.

That realization disturbed him.

"I don't know," he admitted.

Dr. Barrett nodded.

"That may be an important answer."

Thaddeus left the session angry.

Not at her.

At the question.

What do you want to give Celia?

He took the question to physical therapy.

He took it to dinner.

He took it to bed.

That night, Corbin visited.

Thaddeus's younger brother had avoided discussing the affair directly until then.

They played cards badly for twenty minutes before Thaddeus said, "You think she should divorce me?"

Corbin placed a card down.

"That's not my marriage."

"That's a coward's answer."

"Fine. You want my answer?"

Thaddeus braced.

"I think Celia gets to decide what she can live with."

"Everybody says that."

"Because it's true."

"You don't think eight years matters?"

Corbin stared at him.

"Man, stop using eight years like you served a sentence."

Thaddeus flinched.

The wording was different.

The meaning was the same.

History is not a debt.

Corbin collected the cards.

"You know what Celia did when Dad was sick?"

"Of course."

"She organized half that hospital stay. You were falling apart and she made sure nobody saw it."

Thaddeus looked down.

"I remember."

"Then remember this too. She didn't do that because marriage means one person becomes the other's emergency service forever. She did it because you were both showing up for each other then."

Thaddeus said nothing.

Corbin stood to leave.

At the doorway he paused.

"Maybe stop asking what she owes you. Ask what you owe her now."

After Corbin left, Thaddeus sat in the darkened room.

For the first time, an answer to Dr. Barrett's question began to form.

What did he want to give Celia?

Not another promise.

Not another argument.

Maybe the first thing he could give her was the right to leave without making her feel cruel for doing it.

The thought hurt.

Which was how he knew it might be honest.

Dr. Barrett gave him homework after that session.

"Write down every time this week you want someone to do something because you are uncomfortable," she said.

Thaddeus frowned. "That sounds impossible."

"Excellent. You have identified why it may be useful."

The list grew faster than he expected.

He wanted Corbin to stay longer because the room felt lonely. He wanted a nurse to answer immediately because waiting made him anxious. He wanted his employer to promise his old position would remain unchanged because uncertainty frightened him. He wanted Celia to delay the divorce because finality hurt.

None of those wants were automatically wrong. The problem appeared in the next column Dr. Barrett asked him to add: What does the other person need?

May you like

Thaddeus often did not know.

That absence embarrassed him more than any lecture could have. For years he had described himself as attentive. Yet attention, he was learning, was not remembering someone's coffee order. It was allowing their needs to remain real even when those needs conflicted with his own.

Related Stories

Other posts