Chapter 7 - AN APOLOGY WITH CONDITIONS

Talia waited until Saturday morning to apologize.
She had spent nearly a week constructing the conversation in her head.
That was part of the problem.
Talia liked language best when she could prepare it. She liked lists, planned routes, backup chargers, reservation numbers, and conversations that arrived with an opening sentence and a reasonable destination.
Maya was at the kitchen table drawing shoes in a sketchbook when Talia sat across from her.
Andre was outside washing the car with Devin.
"Can we talk?" Talia asked.
Maya's pencil stopped.
"Am I in trouble?"
Talia felt the question like a bruise.
"No."
Maya waited.
Talia folded her hands.
"I've been thinking about last weekend. I want to say I'm sorry that the ticket situation hurt you."
Maya looked down at her drawing.
"Okay."
Talia heard herself continue even though some part of her already knew she was doing it wrong.
"I wasn't trying to exclude you. I was under a lot of pressure, and the prices changed, and your dad had been busy, so I had to make a fast decision. I thought because you're older, you would understand."
Maya's pencil began moving again.
"I do understand."
Relief rose in Talia too quickly.
"You do?"
"Yeah."
"Good. I just don't want you thinking I don't love you."
Maya shaded the heel of the shoe.
"I know you love me."
Talia smiled cautiously. "Okay."
"You just picked me."
The relief vanished.
"Picked you for what?"
Maya looked up.
"To stay."
Talia opened her mouth.
Maya returned to the drawing.
"I know you love me. Both things can be true."
The sentence sounded too old for ten.
Talia sat very still.
"Maya, I don't want you to think I picked you because you matter less."
"Then why did you pick me?"
Talia had rehearsed answers for this.
You're more mature.
Devin is younger.
It was just one trip.
Your aunt had planned to do fun things with you.
Each answer now sounded like a different way to avoid the same truth.
Maya waited.
Talia looked at the sketchbook.
"Because I thought you would make it easier for me."
Maya's pencil stopped.
Talia felt tears threaten and refused to use them. This apology was not supposed to become a scene in which Maya comforted her.
"I knew Devin would be loud and upset if I told him he couldn't go," Talia said. "I knew your dad would argue with me if I told him before I bought the tickets. And I thought you would be disappointed but quiet. So I chose the person who would make my decision easiest."
Maya stared at her.
Talia continued, voice unsteady.
"That was wrong. Not because it hurt your feelings. Because I made you responsible for being easy."
For several seconds, Maya said nothing.
Then she asked, "Are you going to do it again?"
Talia had expected forgiveness, anger, perhaps tears.
She had not expected a practical question about recurrence.
"No."
Maya's eyebrows pulled together.
"How do you know?"
Talia almost said because I promise.
But promises had become cheap that week.
"I don't know yet," she admitted. "I think I have to change some habits, not just say I won't."
Maya looked back at the page.
"Okay."
Talia felt a desperate urge to ask if she was forgiven.
She stopped herself.
"You don't have to tell me it's okay," she said.
Maya looked surprised.
"But I already said okay."
"I mean... you don't have to make me feel better about it."
Maya thought about that.
"I'm not trying to."
Talia almost smiled.
"Fair enough."
She stood to leave.
Maya spoke again.
"Mom?"
Talia turned.
"What?"
"Can I have Saturday art class?"
Talia blinked. "The one at the community center?"
"Yeah."
"I thought you didn't want it anymore."
Maya shrugged. "I stopped asking because Devin has soccer then."
Talia felt her stomach drop.
"Why would that mean you can't go?"
"Because you take him."
"Your dad can take you."
"Dad works sometimes."
"Then we'll figure it out."
Maya studied her.
"Really?"
Talia nodded.
"Really."
"It's every Saturday for eight weeks."
"I heard you."
"It costs money."
Talia nearly laughed from pain.
"I know classes cost money."
Maya's expression remained serious.
"I can use birthday money."
"No."
The sharpness of the answer made Maya flinch.
Talia softened her voice.
"No, sweetheart. You don't have to buy your way into being allowed to want something. We'll look at the price together. If it's too expensive, we'll talk about it honestly. We won't just decide you shouldn't ask."
Maya lowered her eyes.
"Okay."
This time the word sounded different.
Not forgiveness.
Possibility.
When Andre came inside, Devin trailing water from the hose across the entryway, Talia was still at the kitchen table.
"How'd it go?" Andre asked quietly.
Talia looked toward the stairs where Maya had disappeared with her sketchbook.
"Bad first. Better after I stopped explaining myself."
Andre nodded.
"She wants art class."
"Then let's sign her up."
Talia shook her head. "No. First we're going to check the schedule and the cost with her. I don't want this to become guilt spending."
Andre leaned against the counter.
"That's probably smart."
"Also, your Saturdays might have to change."
He smiled. "There it is."
Talia gave him a tired look. "Repair is apparently inconvenient."
"Good thing we're not choosing the convenient kid anymore."
She winced.
Andre immediately regretted the joke.
"Sorry."
Talia nodded.
"No. Keep saying it when we need to hear it."
Outside, Devin pressed his face against the glass door and shouted that the car still had soap on it.
Andre went back out.
Talia remained at the table.
Maya's drawing was still open.
Two shoes, carefully shaded.
May you like
One larger than the other.
Neither erased to make room for the other.