scribe

Chapter 2 - The First Lie

Daniel dropped his briefcase.

“What happened?”

Emma opened her mouth.

Rebecca answered first.

“They were playing.”

Daniel’s face tightened. “Playing?”

Noah emerged from beside the reading chair, empty-handed now. “We were messing around.”

Emma stared at him. The knife was gone.

Daniel crossed the room and knelt before his daughter. “Emma, look at me.”

She did.

His expression changed when he saw the reddish-purple line on her cheek.

“What did that?”

Emma heard Rebecca’s warning in her head.

Say one word, and tonight will become your fault.

“Scissors,” Emma whispered.

Daniel stood slowly.

“Noah.”

“It was an accident,” Rebecca said.

Daniel turned toward her. “Why were there scissors near her face?”

Rebecca’s composure held. “Because Noah was being stupid. I told him to stop.”

Emma’s stomach twisted.

“No,” she said.

The word escaped before fear could stop it.

Rebecca’s eyes sharpened.

Daniel looked down. “No what?”

Emma swallowed. “She didn’t tell him to stop.”

Silence filled the library.

Noah shifted his weight.

Rebecca gave a weary sigh, as though Emma had disappointed her. “Daniel, she was frightened. She’s remembering it bigger than it was.”

Emma’s face burned.

“You held me.”

Rebecca blinked.

“You held my shoulders.”

Daniel stared at his wife.

Rebecca’s voice hardened by half a degree. “To keep her from falling backward into the chair.”

“That’s not why.”

“Emma.”

Daniel’s tone cut across Rebecca’s.

“Let her speak.”

It was the first time in months Emma had heard him use that voice with Rebecca.

She should have felt safe.

Instead she remembered the strange conversation in the study.

The trust.

The Ashcroft letter.

She looked toward Daniel’s desk. The papers Rebecca had been reviewing earlier were gone.

Daniel followed her gaze.

“What is it?”

Emma hesitated.

Rebecca stepped toward Noah. “He needs to apologize.”

The abrupt change in subject was so obvious that even Daniel noticed.

“Where are the scissors?” he asked.

Noah shrugged. “I dropped them.”

“And the knife?”

Emma’s breath caught.

Daniel’s eyes moved to her.

“What knife?”

Rebecca’s face went still.

Noah said, “There wasn’t a knife.”

“There was,” Emma whispered.

Daniel searched the chair, the carpet, and the narrow space between the shelves. Nothing.

Rebecca folded her arms. “This is exactly what I mean. She was scared. Her imagination filled in the rest.”

Emma felt something inside her sink.

Noah had hidden it.

Rebecca had removed it.

And now there was no proof.

Daniel touched Emma’s shoulder gently. “Go upstairs. I’ll come talk to you.”

“I want to stay.”

“Emma—”

“I want to stay.”

Rebecca smiled without warmth. “She’s been difficult lately.”

Daniel’s eyes flicked to Rebecca again.

Emma saw it: the first crack of uncertainty.

Not belief.

Not yet.

But uncertainty.

Daniel sent Noah to his room and asked Rebecca to remain in the library. Emma climbed the grand staircase slowly, then stopped halfway up when voices rose below.

“You let him wave scissors at her?”

“I was right there.”

“That doesn’t answer me.”

“She’s fragile, Daniel. You know that.”

“She is eight.”

“And Noah is ten.”

“He had a knife.”

“She thinks he had a knife.”

Emma gripped the banister.

Then Rebecca said something softer.

“You’re gone three weeks a month. You don’t see what she’s like.”

The words struck with precision.

Daniel traveled constantly for Whitmore & Hale, the investment firm he had inherited from his father. Rebecca had spent years telling him she managed everything at home because he could not.

Emma had begun to wonder whether Rebecca was not merely managing the house.

Maybe she was managing him.

That night Daniel came to Emma’s bedroom with an ice pack and sat beside her.

“Tell me exactly what happened.”

Emma did.

All of it.

Except the study conversation.

When she finished, Daniel rubbed both hands over his face.

“I believe you were afraid.”

Emma’s eyes filled.

“That’s not the same as believing me.”

Daniel looked wounded.

Before he could answer, Emma asked, “Dad, what’s a guardian provision?”

He went motionless.

The rain tapped the windows.

“Why are you asking that?”

Emma’s pulse thudded.

“I heard Rebecca say it.”

Daniel’s expression changed completely.

“Where?”

“In the study.”

“When?”

“Before Noah came into the library.”

Daniel stood.

“What else did you hear?”

Emma remembered the name.

May you like

“The Ashcroft letter.”

For the first time in her life, she saw fear on her father’s face.

Related Stories

Other posts