scribe

Chapter 3 - Claire’s Notebook

Elizabeth kept Claire’s old belongings in a cedar trunk at the back of the upstairs storage room.

She had not opened it in six years.

Sophie sat cross-legged on the floor while her mother lifted out folded sweaters, theater programs, a cracked music box, and a stack of notebooks bound with faded elastic bands.

“Was Aunt Claire good at math?” Sophie asked.

Elizabeth smiled faintly.

“Better than I was.”

“Was she like me?”

Elizabeth looked at her.

“In some ways.”

Sophie waited.

Elizabeth knew what the real question was.

Was Claire also told she was not smart enough?

Elizabeth pulled a blue notebook from the stack.

“Claire hated being underestimated.”

The notebook was from 2004.

Inside were pages of algebra, geometry, and economics notes. Claire had been fourteen that year, far older than Hawthorne’s elementary grades.

That made the school record even stranger.

Sophie leaned closer.

“There.”

Three diagonal slashes beside a difficult equation.

Exactly like the marks on the math test.

Elizabeth’s skin prickled.

“Someone copied her notation.”

“Why?”

“I don’t know.”

She turned more pages.

Near the middle, several sheets had been torn out.

On the next intact page Claire had written one sentence in block letters.

HAWTHORNE NUMBERS DON’T ADD UP.

Elizabeth sat back.

Sophie whispered, “What does that mean?”

“I don’t know.”

Below the sentence was a list.

Briar Fund.

North Hall renovation.

Scholarship reserve.

Caldwell Foundation transfer.

Elizabeth’s pulse quickened.

Their father, Edward Caldwell, had run the Caldwell Foundation, a private charitable trust created from family real-estate holdings. Claire had shown little interest in finance. Or so Elizabeth had believed.

A small folded paper slipped from the notebook.

It was a photocopy of a check.

$450,000.

Payable to Hawthorne Preparatory Academy.

Signed by Edward Caldwell.

Dated December 14, 2004.

Elizabeth stared at it.

Her father had never mentioned donating nearly half a million dollars to Hawthorne.

At the bottom Claire had written:

WHY IS DAD PAYING THEM AFTER I FOUND THE LEDGER?

Sophie read it too.

“Ledger?”

Elizabeth closed the notebook.

“That’s enough for tonight.”

Sophie frowned. “But I can help.”

“I know.”

“Then why are you stopping?”

Because Elizabeth remembered something.

In January 2005, Claire had suddenly been sent to a boarding school in Vermont.

Their parents had said she needed “more structure.”

Three months later, she returned withdrawn and furious.

For years Elizabeth assumed it was teenage rebellion.

Now she wondered if Claire had been punished for discovering something.

The doorbell rang.

Both of them froze.

It was after nine.

Elizabeth went downstairs alone.

Through the glass panel, she saw Ms. Rebecca Hale standing on the porch.

Elizabeth opened the door but did not invite her in.

“You shouldn’t be here.”

“I know.”

“Then why are you?”

Rebecca looked exhausted.

“Because I lied this morning.”

Elizabeth’s expression hardened.

“About what?”

“I knew Claire.”

“How?”

Rebecca looked past her toward the dark hallway.

“I was a student teacher at Hawthorne in 2004.”

Elizabeth said nothing.

“Claire came to the school after hours. She was looking for financial records.”

“Why?”

“She believed someone was stealing from your family foundation.”

Elizabeth’s breath caught.

Rebecca continued.

“She asked me where archived board files were kept. I thought she was just being dramatic. Then I found her in the administrative office one evening with a ledger.”

“The ledger she wrote about?”

Rebecca nodded.

“She said Hawthorne was receiving money from a scholarship fund that didn’t exist.”

“What happened?”

Rebecca’s face tightened.

“I told the headmaster.”

Elizabeth stared at her.

“You reported her?”

“I thought I was protecting her.”

“What happened next?”

“Your father arrived. So did two board members.”

“Who?”

Rebecca hesitated.

“One was Charles Price.”

Elizabeth knew the name.

Charles Price was now chairman of Hawthorne’s board.

He was also the grandfather of Hannah Price—the girl whose test Sophie had supposedly copied.

Rebecca looked ashamed.

“Claire was taken home.”

“And the ledger?”

“Gone.”

Elizabeth’s voice became quiet.

“Why did you tell Sophie she wasn’t capable of that score?”

Rebecca flinched.

“I was angry. I saw the identical tests and the note, and I let an old memory control my judgment.”

“What old memory?”

“Claire lied to me once.”

“About what?”

Rebecca’s eyes filled with regret.

“She told me she had copied the ledger. I believed her. Years later I learned she hadn’t copied it at all.”

Elizabeth folded her arms.

“Then why are we talking about it?”

“Because I found out she hid the original.”

Silence.

“Where?”

Rebecca looked toward the staircase.

“I never knew. But someone believed I did.”

“Who?”

Rebecca reached into her handbag and pulled out an envelope.

Inside was a photocopy of an anonymous note.

SAME ANSWERS. SAME MISTAKES.

Underneath:

THE CALDWELL GIRL WILL LEAD US TO IT.

Elizabeth felt cold.

“Where did you get this?”

“It was under my windshield tonight.”

Sophie’s voice came from the stairs.

“Mom?”

Elizabeth turned.

May you like

Sophie stood halfway down, holding Claire’s blue notebook.

And inside the notebook’s back cover, where neither of them had looked yet, was a small brass key taped beneath the lining.

Related Stories

Other posts