Chapter 13 - The Woman Vesperine Had Been Taught to Be

As a child, Vesperine believed the worst thing a person could do at a party was embarrass her mother. Lavinia maintained beautiful rooms with the discipline of a commander preparing for inspection. Napkins were folded with mathematical precision. Flowers arrived before breakfast. Guests who spoke too loudly were rarely invited twice. Affection existed, but it tended to appear in the form of corrections: straighten your back, lower your voice, do not let them see you need anything.
At sixteen, Vesperine once wore a dress she had sewn herself to a school reception. She had selected the fabric carefully and stayed awake finishing the hem. Lavinia looked her over and said, "How charming that you tried. Now change into something appropriate."
Vesperine never wore the dress again. Years later she barely remembered what color it had been. She remembered instead the relief of entering the reception in a designer gown and hearing her mother say nothing critical. Silence, in that house, was approval.
The memory returned after the wedding because of the quilt. She did not need a therapist to recognize the resemblance between her mother's words and her own. She did, however, need help disentangling explanation from excuse. She began meeting with Dr. Helena Ward, a therapist recommended by someone outside her family's circle. She did not tell Lavinia.
In their second session, Vesperine said, "I can explain exactly why I laughed at that gift. I thought everyone expected me to be witty. I saw something that looked out of place, and I made it into a performance."
"What did you feel when you saw the quilt?" Dr. Ward asked.
"Embarrassment. Then irritation. It wasn't what I'd imagined."
"Why did your irritation require an audience?"
Vesperine sat back. The question felt strangely invasive. "Because I wanted the room to agree with me."
"And when it did?"
"I felt powerful."
Her own answer frightened her. It was easier to describe the event as a joke that went too far than as a moment in which hurting someone had given her pleasure. Yet the first burst of laughter had delighted her. She remembered it exactly.
"Can a person change after enjoying something ugly?" she asked.
"A person can choose different behavior," Dr. Ward replied. "Whether you do will depend on what you practice when you're not being observed."
Vesperine returned to the townhouse on foot. She passed a shop where handmade quilts lay folded behind glass, each tagged with a price far higher than Evadne would ever have imagined charging. It would have been easy to buy the most expensive one and offer it as a replacement. The thought lasted only a moment before she recognized the insult hidden inside it. Money could purchase craftsmanship. It could not reproduce Leontis's childhood or Theodore's Sunday shirt.
The walk home took Vesperine past a small playground. She stopped when she saw a father kneeling to fasten his daughter's coat. The little girl had chosen a bright yellow scarf that clashed spectacularly with her purple gloves. Her father admired the combination with complete sincerity. Vesperine wondered what she would have said if the girl had belonged to her. She might have corrected the colors, improved the photograph and mistaken the correction for love. It startled her to realize she did not know how to admire a thing without comparing it to something better. The child ran away laughing, and the scarf flew behind her like a small flag.
At home, Lavinia was arranging a dinner for friends who had remained loyal. "They must see you calm," she said. "People will follow our lead."
"I don't want a dinner."
"You can't disappear forever."
"I'm not disappearing. I'm refusing to hold a reception to prove I survived another one."
Lavinia set down her pen. "You are becoming dramatic."
Vesperine nearly apologized out of habit. Instead she said, "I need time without being managed."
Her mother looked baffled. Vesperine felt the familiar hunger for approval rise and chose not to feed it. She went upstairs, opened the apology document and added a sentence: "I cannot undo the laughter. I can stop pretending it was anyone's fault but mine."
She still did not publish it. She wanted to give it first to Evadne, but Leontis had asked her not to contact his grandmother. She drafted a letter instead and gave it to Edgar for delivery only if June agreed. For the first time in her life, Vesperine found herself writing words without any guarantee that they would be read. She wondered whether goodness was still real when nobody watched, praised, or rewarded it. The question frightened her because she had built so much of her identity around being noticed and approved of.
Later she received a call from Celia Hart, an old acquaintance who had attended the wedding and written to Evadne. Celia said she was ashamed of laughing. Vesperine expected sympathy to follow; instead Celia admitted she was taking a break from gatherings where people treated cruelty as sophistication.
"You make it sound as if our whole world is rotten," Vesperine said.
"No," Celia answered. "I'm saying I can't blame my laugh on the room anymore. You shouldn't either."
May you like
After the call, Vesperine stared at a framed wedding photograph her mother had arranged to be delivered despite everything. It showed her smiling beside Leontis, his face turned toward her with a trust that now seemed almost unbearable. Behind them a chandelier glittered, indifferent and flawless.
She took the photograph from its frame and placed it in a drawer. She did not tear it. Destroying the image would not improve the person in it. She had once believed that controlling appearances was the same as controlling truth. Now truth had escaped her, and perhaps she could finally begin to meet it.