scribe

Chapter 2 - The Photograph That Should Not Exist

Adrien did not speak for several seconds.

Cael stared at the photograph until her eyes hurt.

Eli looked younger by perhaps a year, wearing the battered brown jacket he loved. Varessa stood beside him outside a brick building with a blue awning. Her hand rested lightly on his shoulder. Between them was a cardboard banker’s box marked HARROW STREET HOLDINGS.

“What is that?” Cael asked.

Adrien turned the picture upright. “You tell me.”

“I’ve never seen it.”

“Your brother knew Malken.”

“I knew that much.”

“No. You knew they argued.”

Cael looked at him sharply.

Adrien tapped the image. “This doesn’t look like an argument.”

Cael wanted to say photographs lied. She wanted to say Eli could smile when he hated someone. Instead she remembered the dark hallway three days before his death, when she had gone to his apartment and heard Varessa’s voice through the door.

You can’t keep pretending this belongs to you.

Eli’s reply had been too low to understand.

Then Varessa: If Mercer finds out, we’re both finished.

Cael had forgotten the name until that moment.

“Mercer,” she said.

Adrien’s eyes narrowed. “What?”

“Someone named Mercer.”

He opened Varessa’s witness statement. Most of it concerned a burglary case in which she had testified eight years earlier. The page mentioning Eli was oddly sparse. It said only that Elias Dorne had been “an occasional courier contracted for document transport.”

Courier.

Cael almost laughed.

Eli repaired cars. He borrowed money. He lost jobs. He had never mentioned transporting legal documents.

Adrien leaned back. “Your brother’s death was classified as an armed robbery gone wrong.”

“I know what they classified it as.”

“Did the police ever tell you he was working for a property company?”

“No.”

Adrien closed the folder.

Cael’s anger shifted shape.

It had always been a blade pointed at Varessa. Now it split into branches.

“Let me talk to her.”

“No.”

“You want the truth?”

“I want to know whether this assault was retaliation, premeditated violence, or something connected to another crime.”

“You sound like a cop.”

“I was one.”

She had heard rumors. Adrien had spent fourteen years in county investigations before joining corrections after an internal dispute. Nobody knew why.

He gathered the photographs.

“Your disciplinary hearing is in three days,” he said. “Until then, you’re separated from Malken.”

“Where is she?”

“Medical observation.”

“Is she hurt?”

“Not badly.”

Cael hated the relief that passed through her.

Adrien noticed anyway.

“You wanted her hurt,” he said, “but maybe not dead.”

Cael stared at him.

“I wanted my brother back.”

“That option was never on the table.”

He left.

That night, confined to a segregation cell, Cael lay awake beneath a thin blanket while the ventilation system hummed.

At 2:13 a.m., a folded piece of paper slid beneath her door.

She sat up.

No footsteps followed.

The note contained six words.

YOUR BROTHER STOLE FROM THE WRONG MAN.

On the back was a hand-drawn symbol: a square divided by a diagonal line.

Cael knew it.

Eli had carved the same symbol into the wooden workbench in their father’s garage when they were teenagers.

Before Adrien dismissed her, Cael asked to see the photograph again. He set it beneath the interview-room light. The blue awning was faded. A delivery truck was reflected in the glass behind Eli and Varessa. On the truck door, almost lost in glare, were the words MERIDIAN ACCESS SERVICES.

Cael touched the edge of the photograph with one finger. “He wore that jacket the week he died.”

“You’re sure?”

“He tore the left cuff fixing Mom’s sink. I sewed it badly. You can see the black thread.”

Adrien leaned closer. The cuff was visible. That placed the photograph within days, not months, of Eli’s death.

“Who took the picture?” Cael asked.

“Unknown.”

“Then find out.”

Adrien gave her a look that reminded her she was not directing the investigation.

Cael exhaled. “Please.”

The word cost her more than she liked.

Later, in segregation, she replayed the last real conversation she had had with Eli. He had shown up at her apartment with takeout and asked, too casually, whether she had ever signed anything for their father’s estate. She had mocked him for sounding like a lawyer. He asked whether she still had the old lockbox from the garage. She said no. He changed the subject.

At the time she thought he was being nosy.

Now every ordinary question looked like a warning she had missed.

A female officer named Mendez brought Cael dinner and paused at the slot. “You’ve got half the unit talking about that transfer.”

“Half the unit talks about weather like it’s organized crime.”

Mendez almost smiled. “Malken asked whether you were okay.”

Cael’s expression hardened. “Tell her nothing.”

“I’m not your messenger.”

“Good.”

Mendez closed the slot.

Cael sat on the bunk with the meal untouched. The strangest part was not that Varessa had asked. It was that concern fit the photograph better than hatred did.

When lights dimmed, Cael tried to reconstruct the dark hallway memory. She had seen only part of the argument through a half-open stairwell door. Varessa had been shouting, yes. But Eli had not sounded afraid. He sounded furious.

And the sentence Cael remembered most clearly—You can’t keep pretending this belongs to you—could have referred to money, land, documents, or something else entirely.

For eight years, she had supplied the missing noun herself: my brother’s life.

That certainty no longer held.

May you like

He had told her it was meaningless.

For the first time in eight years, she wondered if he had lied.

Related Stories

Other posts