Chapter 18 - A Law Written for Dead Kings

The succession statute had been written after a civil war eighty-three years earlier.
That fact mattered.
Brother Caldus found the original commentary in a locked archive chest, its pages stiff with age. The law requiring an appointed midwife and two sworn women had not been designed to punish mothers or regulate childbirth.
It had been written to prevent nobles from producing an unrelated infant after a royal child died unseen.
“The purpose was verification of identity,” Caldus explained. “Not bureaucratic control of the room.”
Sunniva sat beside him in the archive while rain struck the windows.
“So if three credible women saw Caelan born alive…”
“The purpose of the law is satisfied.”
“Even if Odo removed the women originally assigned?”
“Especially then, I would argue.”
A smile touched Sunniva’s mouth.
“You enjoy this.”
“I enjoy old lawmakers failing to anticipate clever criminals.”
The public succession hearing was scheduled for the next day.
Duke Edwyn had agreed to keep his soldiers outside the walls until the council ruled. His captains were restless. Rumors moved through the city that the royal child was sick, switched, dead, illegitimate, or imaginary.
Odo had prepared well.
He had understood that people did not need proof when fear offered a more interesting story.
That afternoon, Alaric met Edwyn privately.
Sunniva insisted on being present.
Edwyn entered without complaint.
Alaric placed the intercepted 3/2 letter on the table.
“Your captain Brenn received this from Odo’s secretary.”
Edwyn read it.
His face hardened.
“I did not authorize this correspondence.”
“What did Brenn tell you?”
“That the capital might fall into factional fighting if the birth was disputed.”
“And your answer was to bring six hundred soldiers?” Sunniva asked.
“My answer was to ensure no faction seized the palace.”
“Which faction did you imagine would seize it?”
Edwyn looked at her.
She continued. “The king controls the guard. The child’s mother was recovering in bed. Mirelda had no troops. Roderic had no army. Only one man benefited from convincing you the capital was about to collapse.”
Edwyn’s jaw tightened.
“Odo.”
“Yes.”
Alaric said, “Did he ever promise you anything?”
“No.”
“Did he ever discuss the succession?”
“Every chancellor discusses succession.”
“Answer.”
Edwyn exhaled.
“Two months ago he said the kingdom would accept me if tragedy left the throne uncertain.”
Sunniva’s stomach tightened.
“What did you say?”
“I told him I would never move against you.” Edwyn looked at Alaric. “And I did not.”
“You marched.”
“I marched after receiving reports that half the palace guard had changed allegiance.”
Venn, standing near the door, said, “That report was false.”
“I know that now.”
Sunniva studied Edwyn.
He was ambitious. That did not automatically make him part of the attack.
Ambition was not proof.
“What will you do tomorrow?” she asked.
Edwyn looked at her.
“If the evidence satisfies me, I will recognize the boy.”
Alaric bristled. “Your satisfaction is not the law.”
“No. But the western lords listen to me. Pretending otherwise would be foolish.”
Sunniva appreciated the plainness.
“Then listen carefully tomorrow.”
After he left, Venn said, “I still do not trust him.”
“Neither do I,” Sunniva replied.
Alaric frowned. “You just defended him.”
“No. I defended the difference between suspicion and evidence.”
Alaric looked at her for a long time.
“That distinction is becoming inconvenient.”
“It is supposed to be.”
A messenger arrived from the city archive before dusk.
He carried a registry book documenting Odo’s purchases through intermediaries.
One entry, dated three weeks before Caelan’s birth, showed payment for printing two hundred broadsheets.
The title was already set in type.
THE FALSE HEIR OF SUNNIVA.
The sheets had been prepared before the child was born.
Caldus found one more annotation in the old statute commentary: in emergencies, witnesses could be ‘such trustworthy household persons as are present and capable of oath.’ The phrase had not been copied into later summaries because earlier clerks considered it obvious. Odo’s office had circulated the shortened version for years.
“Was that deliberate?” Alaric asked.
Caldus shrugged. “I cannot prove it. But a summary that omits exceptions tends to make the summarizer powerful.”
Sunniva asked that the full statute and commentary be copied and posted before the hearing. She wanted no advocate, including her own, quoting fragments without context.
Odo objected from confinement through his counsel, claiming publication could prejudice the council.
“The law prejudices the council?” Sunniva asked.
Caldus smiled. “Apparently.”
Meanwhile, Edwyn sent Captain Brenn to request private access to Odo. Venn denied it. Brenn claimed he carried questions on behalf of western lords. When asked to submit them in writing, he withdrew the request.
That behavior did not prove conspiracy, but it gave Venn reason to watch him.
Sunniva slept badly that night. Not because she feared the law would fail, but because she now understood how close it had come to being reduced to Odo’s summary of itself. Institutions, like people, could forget their original purpose if convenience repeated long enough.
May you like
Odo had planned not only the crime.
He had planned the rumor that would follow it.