scribe

Chapter 9 - THE SISTER WHO DIDN’T EXIST

Lucian called Mara’s mother before dawn.

Evelyn Arden lived in Florence and had not returned to Voss Manor since the funeral. Grief had turned distance into survival.

When Lucian told her about the photograph, she went silent for so long he thought the call had dropped.

“Evelyn?”

“I’m here.”

“What does it mean?”

Another silence.

Then she said, “Mara made me promise.”

Lucian closed his eyes.

“Promise what?”

“That I would never tell you unless she did first.”

His exhaustion became anger. “She’s dead.”

“I know.”

“And Elara nearly died yesterday.”

Evelyn inhaled sharply.

Lucian had not told her the full story yet.

He did now.

When he finished, Evelyn was crying.

“There was another daughter,” she whispered.

Lucian sat down.

“What?”

“Before I married Mara’s father, I was seventeen. I had twins.”

The world seemed to contract around him.

“Mara was one?”

“Yes.”

“And the other?”

“A girl named Serena.”

“What happened to her?”

“I was told she died.”

Lucian’s skin prickled.

“Told by whom?”

“The maternity home. It was run by a religious charity. They said Serena stopped breathing six hours after birth. I never saw her body.”

“Why did Mara know?”

“Because she found the original admission papers after my mother died. They listed two live births.”

Lucian looked at Mara’s photograph again.

Sabine beside her.

She trusted the wrong sister.

“Did Mara believe Serena was alive?”

“Yes.”

“Did she find her?”

“I don’t know. She stopped discussing it three months before Elara was born.”

Lucian rubbed his forehead.

“When did she first meet Sabine?”

“Years ago. At a charity gala.”

“Did she ever suspect Sabine?”

Evelyn hesitated.

“She once asked me whether twins always resemble each other.”

Lucian stood.

“What did you say?”

“Not necessarily. Especially fraternal twins.”

“Evelyn, what was the name of the maternity charity?”

She told him.

Bellamy House for Mothers and Infants.

Lucian’s entire body went cold.

Bellamy.

Sabine’s family.

He called Hale immediately.

By ten that morning, Hale had obtained archived corporate records. Bellamy House had been founded by Sabine’s grandmother forty-two years earlier.

The maternity home had closed after allegations of illegal adoptions.

No criminal charges were ever filed.

Hale spread photocopies across the manor’s library table.

“Your mother-in-law—Mara’s mother—gave birth there. Two girls. One supposedly died.”

“And Sabine’s family controlled the home.”

“Yes.”

Lucian stared at an old staff photograph.

A young woman stood beside the founder.

Underneath was a caption: NORA BELLAMY, DIRECTOR OF PLACEMENTS.

Sabine’s mother.

Lucian felt the pieces move again.

Maybe Mara had investigated Sabine because of the trust.

Maybe she had investigated her because of Serena.

Maybe the two were connected.

Hale slid another document across the table.

“This is where it gets stranger.”

It was a sealed-adoption index released after Bellamy House closed.

One female infant, born the same date as Mara, had been transferred under a temporary name.

Baby S.A.

Receiving family: confidential.

But in the margin was a handwritten notation.

N.B. REQUEST — KEEP WITH FAMILY.

Lucian looked at Hale.

“Nora Bellamy kept Serena?”

“We don’t know.”

A knock came at the library door.

Anton entered holding an envelope delivered by courier.

No return address.

Inside was a single DNA laboratory report.

Lucian read the names.

Mara Arden Voss.

Sabine Bellamy Voss.

Probability of full sibling relationship: 99.72%.

Lucian could not speak.

Hale whispered, “Someone wants you to know.”

At the bottom of the report, beneath the laboratory stamp, someone had written another message.

ASK SABINE WHO HER REAL MOTHER IS.

Evelyn sent Lucian a photograph taken minutes after the twins were born.

It was faded and badly exposed, but two newborn girls were visible in separate hospital bassinets. Mara wore a paper band around one tiny wrist. The second baby wore only a handwritten tag: S.A.

"Serena Arden," Evelyn said over video call. "That was the name I chose before they told me she was dead."

Lucian enlarged the image.

In the background, half out of frame, stood a young Nora Bellamy.

That was no longer rumor.

Nora had been physically present.

Evelyn covered her mouth when she saw her clearly for the first time.

"I remember that woman," she whispered. "She told me to rest. She said the second baby had been taken for observation."

Lucian's anger rose on behalf of a seventeen-year-old girl he had not known.

"Did anyone let you sign papers?"

"So many. I was medicated. My mother told me not to read them."

The old adoption scandal stopped being an abstract institutional crime.

It was a room.

A frightened teenager.

A woman saying rest while a child was carried away.

Later, Hale's team verified the DNA report linking Mara and Sabine. The laboratory had processed samples six months earlier under anonymous identifiers. Mara had paid through a personal account.

"So the report delivered today is a copy of a real test," Hale said.

"Who had it?"

"Mara. The laboratory. Possibly whoever searched her phone or papers."

Lucian thought of Gideon removing the phone from evidence.

Another possibility emerged.

If Gideon knew Mara and Sabine were sisters before Mara died, then family exposure was not merely financial. Public revelation would show that the Bellamys had secretly raised a stolen child from the very system their foundation claimed to have reformed.

Sabine was both evidence and scandal.

Lucian looked at the delivered report again.

"Whoever sent this wants pressure on Sabine."

Hale nodded. "Or wants us to distrust her more."

"Those are not mutually exclusive."

"No."

For the first time, Lucian understood that anonymous truth could still be manipulation.

May you like

Someone could reveal a real fact at the exact moment it caused maximum damage.

That realization would matter later.

Related Stories

Other posts