Chapter 3 - The Question He Couldn't Answer

Cole recovered with a laugh that arrived a fraction too late.
“Is this because I haven't picked out the groomsmen's ties?”
“No.”
“Then where is this coming from?”
“Answer the question.”
He pushed off the doorway and approached her. “Of course we'll get married. That's what the whole wedding is for.”
Maren watched him carefully. He had not said yes. He had described an event already on the calendar, a machine that might roll forward without anyone examining its purpose.
“Do you want to?” she asked.
“Why are you interrogating me?”
“Because I'm asking about the rest of my life.”
He crossed his arms. “I've had the week from hell. Can we please not do this tonight?”
Three days earlier, she would have apologized for bad timing. Instead she picked up her case.
“We can finish tomorrow.”
She went upstairs and heard him mutter that she was being dramatic. The word followed her into the guest room, where she discovered that she felt neither dramatic nor brave. She felt sad in a way that made the furniture look unfamiliar.
The following morning, she called the Denver boutique and arranged for the dress to remain in storage. Then she called the caterer, who confirmed the final payment deadline. She asked what could be recovered if the event were canceled. The woman on the phone paused before explaining the refund terms with practiced kindness.
Maren thanked her and wrote everything down. She called the florist, the venue, and the photographer. There were deposits she would never see again. She did not pretend otherwise. The money was lost because she had believed a promise, but losing the money did not require her to lose another fourteen weeks.
Each call gave Maren a different version of disappointment. The florist asked whether the date should be held while they talked things over. The photographer offered to transfer the deposit to a future celebration. The venue manager quietly said that many couples needed time before making final decisions. Maren appreciated the kindness, but she refused to borrow uncertainty from strangers. After the last call, she placed the contract copies in a folder and labeled it WEDDING—CLOSED, then sat still until the words stopped making her hands shake.
Nadia reviewed the vendor contracts and the source of each payment. Maren had covered most of the wedding expenses, while Cole had paid the venue deposit. Nadia advised her not to cancel or redirect anything involving Cole's funds without notifying him and documenting the arrangement. Maren sent him an email asking for a meeting that evening and saying they needed to make a final decision about the event.
He called within six minutes.
“Why are you making this sound like a corporate merger?”
“Because you keep refusing to have an honest conversation.”
“I'm in the middle of a job site.”
“Then we'll speak tonight.”
She ended the call before he could move the conversation somewhere easier for himself.
At six, he came home with takeout from the restaurant where they had celebrated their second anniversary. The gesture nearly undid her. Cole remembered important things when he was frightened of losing comfort. He just seemed unable to remember them before.
“Peace offering,” he said.
“Sit down, Cole.”
He set the bags on the island. “You're scaring me.”
“On Tuesday night, while you were on the patio with your friends, I came home early.”
The color drained from his face. No elaborate confession was necessary. His reaction confirmed that he remembered exactly what he had said.
“How much did you hear?”
“Enough.”
“Maren—”
“Did you say you'd rather die than marry me?”
He looked away.
“I was joking.”
“Did you say you would postpone the wedding again?”
“Guys talk garbage when they've been drinking.”
“Did you say you loved your life with me, instead of saying you loved me?”
Cole stared at the table. The takeout containers cooled between them.
“I didn't mean it like that.”
“What did you mean?”
“I'm scared of marriage. Dad was miserable toward the end, Mom was miserable, everybody acts like a piece of paper fixes things. I didn't want to disappoint you.”
“Then you should have told me before I planned a wedding.”
“You would have left.”
“Yes,” Maren said. “I might have.”
He looked up sharply, as though her agreement were the unkindest thing she'd said.
“You were my choice to make,” she continued. “You kept information from me because you wanted to control my choice.”
“I never controlled you.”
“You kept accepting everything I was building for us while you planned not to follow through. You knew I wouldn't agree to that arrangement.”
He rubbed both hands down his face. “I love you.”
She felt the words strike somewhere tender. She had waited for them all week, even while telling herself they could no longer fix anything. But love spoken only when the benefits of silence were threatened no longer felt like an answer.
“I believe you love something about me,” she said. “I'm not sure you've loved me as a person who gets to make decisions.”
Cole pulled out a chair. “What do you want me to do? I'll marry you. We can go to the courthouse tomorrow. I'll prove it.”
Maren remembered him on the patio, speaking freely because he believed she couldn't hear.
“I don't want to marry someone who offers it as emergency damage control.”
He leaned forward. “Then tell me how to fix this.”
She slid the vendor list across the table. Beside it lay the written transition plan for Hargrove Restoration, a schedule for separating their accounts, and Nadia's proposed agreement concerning his move from her house.
“I've called off the wedding,” she said. “And I'm ending our engagement.”
Cole glanced at the pages. His eyes stopped on the business transition inventory, and something like panic replaced his grief.
“You can't stop managing the company right now,” he said. “The insurance renewal is next week.”
May you like
Maren had wondered which loss he would name first.
Now she knew.