Chapter 22 - The Apology

Seraphina did not open Honora’s letter.
She showed the sealed envelope to Dr. Greene first and then asked Ellie what she wanted to do.
“Do I have to read it?”
“No.”
“Can you read it first?”
“Yes.”
The letter was handwritten.
Honora apologized for asking Ellie to purchase meals, for making comments about her family’s money, and for touching her in anger. She admitted she had convinced herself that the requests were harmless because the amounts were small.
She also wrote that she had been angry at parents and school culture and had unfairly directed that resentment toward children.
It was more complete than the apology at mediation.
But one sentence troubled Seraphina:
I hope someday you can forgive me so we can both move forward.
That placed a small burden back on Ellie.
Seraphina explained this before giving her the letter.
“You don’t owe forgiveness because someone asks for it.”
Ellie read slowly.
When she finished, she folded the page.
“Is she telling the truth?”
“I don’t know what she feels. The things she admits happened.”
“Do you forgive her?”
“This isn’t my apology to answer.”
Ellie frowned.
“I don’t know.”
“You don’t have to know today.”
They placed the letter in a drawer.
Days passed.
Ellie did not mention it.
Then, during a counseling session, she said, “I think I don’t want to hate her.”
Dr. Greene asked, “Is that the same as forgiving her?”
“I don’t know.”
“It doesn’t have to be.”
Ellie decided not to respond.
That choice was important too.
Honora had spent weeks demanding responses from her: buy this, answer that, explain yourself, prove you are good.
Now Ellie could receive a request and leave it unanswered.
At school, preparations began for a fall family luncheon. Students would eat with parents in the decorated cafeteria.
Ellie initially refused to attend.
Too many associations.
Too much lunch.
Seraphina said they could skip it.
Then Ellie changed her mind.
“I want to go.”
On the day of the luncheon, Seraphina arrived wearing the cream wrap cardigan Ellie associated with home and safety. Ellie met her at the cafeteria doors.
Tables were covered with paper leaves. Parents talked too loudly. Children traded desserts.
Mrs. Alvarez served chicken sandwiches among several options.
Ellie stared at them.
Then chose one.
Seraphina chose the same.
They sat together.
Halfway through the meal Ellie laughed at something Nora said from the next table.
Seraphina realized she had not seen Ellie check the faculty-room door once.
After lunch, Ellie reached into her wallet.
“I want to buy a cookie.”
Seraphina smiled. “Your money.”
Ellie bought one chocolate-chip cookie.
She broke it in half.
“Want some?”
Seraphina accepted.
May you like
This was generosity without fear.
And it tasted entirely different.