scribe

Chapter 3 - A Dinner Full of Empty Chairs

Gordon's birthday dinner took place in the same house where I had learned to apologize for things I had not done. The windows faced the Charles River. A grandfather clock stood beside the stairs. The dining room still smelled faintly of lemon polish, though the woman who had once polished every surface was gone.

Adrian came with me. Theo stayed at the hotel with a sitter recommended by its concierge, a woman we had met and checked beforehand. I would not bring my son into an argument that could become unpredictable. Gordon objected when he saw Adrian at the door.

“This is a family matter.”

“He is my family,” I said.

My father looked away first. Inside, my stepmother Vivian greeted us with a smile that stopped at her eyes. She had married Gordon eighteen months after Helen died. In the years that followed, she had mastered the art of giving instructions in the tone of a concerned relative.

Brielle sat near the fireplace, her hands wrapped around a glass of sparkling water. Graham stood behind her chair. Their wedding photograph rested on the mantel, but it was a small picture, nearly hidden by silver candlesticks. Nobody had removed it for my benefit. That would have required acknowledging how much it hurt.

A place had been set for me beside Gordon, where I sat when visitors came. Vivian used to call that seat the place of honor. From there I was expected to smile at business guests and avoid interrupting when men discussed money. Across the table, Brielle had always been encouraged to speak because her stories were entertaining. I had mistaken that difference for personality until I grew old enough to notice how one child was praised for being visible and the other for being silent. Vivian had arranged a vase of my mother's favorite tulips at the center of the table. I wondered if she remembered the flowers or their effect on me. Adrian touched the back of my chair once as we sat. It was a gesture, but it reminded me I could leave whenever I needed to. For the first time, that possibility did not feel like running away.

Dinner began with forced civility. Gordon asked about Seattle. Vivian complimented my dress. Brielle said she wanted to meet Theo. Graham kept looking at Adrian's wedding band as if he could make it disappear through concentration.

Eventually Gordon raised his glass.

“To second chances.”

I left mine untouched.

“Before we toast,” I said, “I want to ask about the document assigning my interest in Harbor House.”

Forks stopped moving. Vivian put down her napkin.

“What document?” she asked, too quickly.

“A signed assignment recorded after I left.”

Gordon cleared his throat. “Your mother wanted the property used responsibly.”

“She wanted apprentices to learn there. What happened to that?”

“The classes continued,” he said. “For a time.”

“Then?”

“Financial reality intervened.”

Brielle stared at her plate. Graham spoke carefully.

“Harbor House needed substantial repairs. We arranged financing.”

“With whose authority?” I asked.

“Yours,” Gordon answered.

I looked directly at him. “I did not sign that assignment.”

Vivian's face hardened. “You can't disappear for five years and expect the world to stop.”

“I don't. I expect my signature to remain mine.”

Graham rubbed his forehead. “Natalie, we thought you were dead.”

“Eleven months after I left?”

He looked up.

“That is when the assignment was signed,” I said. “Were you already telling people I was dead by then?”

Nobody answered.

Adrian remained quiet until Gordon turned toward him.

“You must see how complicated this is.”

“I see my wife asking a straightforward question,” Adrian said. “Who witnessed her signature?”

Gordon's fork struck his plate. “I won't be interrogated in my own house.”

“Then don't answer,” I said. “The records will.”

That was when Brielle began to cry. Her tears were real; I had no reason to doubt that. But I remembered how quickly tears had once ended every conversation in which she might have been held accountable.

“Graham and I weren't happy,” she whispered. “We married because Dad needed the partnership. The company was failing. I thought maybe loving him enough would make it work.”

Graham flinched at the word loving. I almost felt sorry for him. Then I remembered the dress, the birthday, and the eight years he had taken from me before deciding I was replaceable.

“You still married him,” I said.

“Yes.”

“And you let everyone tell me I was unreasonable for being devastated.”

She nodded, barely.

The admission was small, but it was the first honest one I had heard all evening.

After dessert nobody touched, Graham followed me into the hallway. Adrian stood near the front door, giving us space while remaining in sight.

“I did look for you,” Graham said. “For months.”

“Then why is there a gravestone calling me your wife?”

His eyes shone. “Because I needed someplace to say goodbye.”

“Goodbye to whom? You married somebody else.”

“I made a mistake.”

“A mistake is taking the wrong exit. You stood at an altar and promised my stepsister a lifetime.”

He swallowed.

“I never stopped loving you.”

The words arrived five years too late and with none of the power he expected.

“Then you should have loved me when I was there,” I answered.

He reached into his jacket and pulled out a small velvet ring box. I recognized it before he opened it. The diamond was mine, the one I had returned when I discovered the wedding. I had believed he sold it.

“I kept this,” he said.

I stepped back. “Put it away.”

His hand trembled. For a moment he looked genuinely lost. Then he said something that made me stop at the door.

“Brielle knows who signed the document.”

I turned.

May you like

“Then tell her to contact my attorney.”

When Adrian and I reached the street, I finally exhaled. I had entered that house hoping someone would tell me the truth. I left knowing the truth was afraid of daylight.

Related Stories

Other posts