Chapter 23 - ORSON MEETS CALEB

The meeting happened at a pizza restaurant because Orson insisted that any person who might become his brother needed to pass what he called "the important test."
"What test?" Estelle asked.
"Pizza choice."
"What answer is correct?"
"Depends."
"On what?"
"I'll know when he says it."
Ellis looked at Estelle.
"Apparently this is serious."
Caleb agreed to a short dinner on a Sunday afternoon.
He arrived wearing jeans, a navy jacket, and the expression of a man walking into a job interview he had not applied for.
Orson saw him first.
"That's him."
Ellis turned.
Caleb paused at the entrance.
For a moment, the resemblance between the three males was startling.
Not identical features. Something subtler. A shared posture when uncertain. The same slight narrowing of the eyes before smiling.
Estelle stood first.
"Caleb. Hi."
He crossed to the table.
"Hi. It's good to finally meet you."
They shook hands, then laughed at the formality.
"I'm not sure what the protocol is," Caleb admitted.
"There isn't one," Estelle said. "That's probably good."
Orson was staring.
Caleb looked down at him.
"You must be Orson."
"You look like Dad."
Ellis closed his eyes.
"We discussed not opening with that."
"No, you discussed it. I didn't agree."
Caleb laughed.
"It's okay. People have been saying that a lot lately."
Orson pointed at the empty chair beside him.
"You can sit there."
Caleb sat.
A server brought menus.
Orson did not open his.
"What pizza do you like?"
Caleb glanced at Ellis.
"This is the test, isn't it?"
"Yes."
"Pepperoni. Mushrooms if they're cooked enough. No pineapple."
Orson's eyes widened.
"Correct."
Estelle laughed.
"What if he had said pineapple?"
"Then we would need more time."
The adults laughed harder than the joke deserved because laughter gave them somewhere to put the tension.
Dinner lasted ninety minutes.
Orson asked twenty-seven questions.
Did Caleb have a dog? No.
Could he ride a bicycle with no hands? Briefly.
Did he have a girlfriend? Caleb nearly choked on water.
Did he know Dad snored? Estelle answered that one.
Did he call Ellis Dad?
The table went quiet.
Caleb looked at Orson.
"No. I call him Ellis."
Orson frowned. "Why?"
Ellis started to speak, but Caleb answered.
"Because I already had a dad who raised me. His name was Terrence. He died. Ellis is my biological father, but we're still figuring out what we call each other."
Orson absorbed that.
"Can you have two dads?"
"I think people can have a lot of different kinds of family."
"But Terrence is your dad even if Ellis is your father?"
Caleb's eyes softened.
"Yes."
Orson nodded.
"Okay."
That was all.
Adults spent weeks preparing explanations children sometimes accepted in seconds.
After pizza, Orson asked Caleb to play a racing game on the small arcade machine near the restrooms.
Caleb agreed.
Ellis and Estelle watched from the table.
Orson immediately began explaining the controls despite the fact that Caleb was twenty-four and presumably understood steering.
"How are you?" Estelle asked Ellis.
He looked at the two of them.
"Terrified. Happy. Sad. Guilty. Grateful. Pick one."
"No need."
Caleb lost the first race.
Orson celebrated loudly.
"He let him win," Ellis said.
"Of course he did."
In the second race, Caleb stopped being generous and beat Orson by half a lap.
Orson stared at the screen in betrayal.
Caleb grinned.
"Welcome to family," Estelle murmured.
On the way home, Orson sat in the back seat holding a small plastic racing token Caleb had given him.
"I like him," he announced.
Ellis smiled at the road.
"I'm glad."
"Is he coming to the house next time?"
"Maybe," Estelle said.
"Can he sleep over?"
Ellis laughed. "He's an adult with his own apartment."
"Adults can sleep over."
"Not yet, O."
Orson sighed dramatically.
Then he was quiet for several minutes.
"Dad?"
"Yeah?"
"Were you sad when you found out you missed him growing up?"
Ellis gripped the steering wheel.
"Yes. Very."
"But you didn't know."
"I know."
"So you can't go backward."
Estelle looked at Ellis.
Orson continued, "You can only do next time."
Ellis smiled through sudden tears.
"That's pretty smart."
"I know."
Estelle reached across the console and rested her hand on Ellis's arm.
He covered it with his own.
In the mirror, Orson saw.
May you like
This time, he did not look away because he was worried.
He looked away because the sight no longer required watching.