Chapter 17 - Ottilie Under Oath

The civil deposition took place in a conference room three weeks later.
Ottilie sat at the far end of a polished table with a court reporter to her left and Pamela Crane beside her.
Vivian's counsel, Thomas Avery, asked the questions.
Gideon was not permitted to attend the entire session, but he received the transcript afterward.
For four hours, Ottilie answered carefully.
Yes, she had met Conrad Pike.
Yes, she had discussed Briarwood.
Yes, she had accepted payment through Merrick Strategy.
No, she did not consider it a kickback.
She described it as compensation for "family asset coordination and stakeholder communications."
Thomas asked, "What stakeholders did you communicate with?"
"My husband. His cousin. Mr. Pike."
"Did you communicate with the trust's independent trustee?"
"Not directly."
"The Wren Conservation Foundation?"
"No."
"The trust beneficiary?"
Pamela objected.
Thomas rephrased.
"Did you communicate with Elowen Vale regarding the proposed sale of property held for her benefit?"
Ottilie looked straight ahead.
"She is a child."
"So no?"
"No."
Then came the altered authority document.
Ottilie denied changing it.
"Did you send the version containing real-property negotiation authority to Pike Development?"
"I sent documents I believed valid."
"Who gave you that version?"
"I don't recall."
"Was it Alistair Vale?"
"I don't recall."
"Did Gideon Vale sign page four in your presence?"
"I don't recall."
Thomas slid a copy across the table.
"Do you recognize the printer identification marks at the bottom margin?"
Pamela objected again.
The marks came from a high-end color printer at the Vale residence.
The home's printer log, recovered from its internal memory, showed the altered page had been printed at 11:42 p.m. on October 7.
Gideon had been in Boston that night.
Ottilie's phone had connected to the home Wi-Fi at 11:39.
"Do you deny printing this page?" Thomas asked.
Ottilie paused.
"I do not remember printing it."
Then came Alder House.
Her posture changed almost imperceptibly.
"Why did you pay a deposit before discussing placement with Gideon?"
"I was gathering options."
"Why did your timeline say Elowen's placement would create room to finish the trustee issue?"
Pamela objected to foundation.
Thomas showed the recovered document.
Ottilie read it.
"I was overwhelmed. I made notes that mixed different problems together."
"Did you intentionally document Elowen as more unstable than she was?"
"No."
"Did you lock her in the vehicle at Briarwood on November 27?"
Ottilie became completely still.
"The vehicle was locked."
"Did you activate the locks from outside?"
"Yes."
"Why?"
"I needed space."
"From a nine-year-old?"
"From escalating conflict."
"What conflict?"
Ottilie looked toward Pamela.
Then she answered.
"She had been disrespectful that morning."
"Describe the disrespect."
A pause.
"She would not stop asking whether we were meeting someone at the garden."
Thomas glanced down at his notes.
"Was she correct?"
Ottilie said nothing.
"Were you scheduled to meet Conrad Pike's land-use consultant in the administration building at 2:20 p.m.?"
Pamela objected.
Ottilie's face lost color.
The meeting had appeared on Pike's produced calendar records.
Thomas continued.
"Did you lock Elowen in the car because you did not want her present for that meeting?"
"No."
"Then why not bring her inside?"
"Because she was upset."
"The security footage shows her calm until after you locked the door."
Silence.
"Mrs. Vale, did you create the very distress you later intended to document as evidence that Elowen required residential placement?"
Pamela instructed her client not to answer pending a privilege consultation.
But the question remained in the transcript like a stain.
After the deposition, Pamela requested a break from settlement discussions.
That evening she called Vivian privately.
"My client may be willing to provide information regarding Pike and Alistair in exchange for resolution of the civil claims."
Vivian answered, "Criminal matters are not mine to bargain away."
"I understand."
"And any agreement involving Elowen's trust requires court approval."
"I understand that too."
Vivian leaned back in her chair.
Ottilie's position had changed.
May you like
For months she had controlled information.
Now information was the only thing she had left to sell.