Chapter 4 - WHAT IMANI SAW

Camille’s phone buzzed three times before noon.
She ignored the first vibration because she was presenting quarterly enrollment numbers to her director. She ignored the second because she was answering an email from a parent who had mistaken urgency for permission to be rude. By the third, she was alone in the copy room with a stack of forms in her hand and no reasonable excuse not to look.
IMANI: Call me when you can.
Camille stared at the message.
She almost put the phone back into her bag.
Instead, she called.
Imani answered before the second ring. “You okay?”
“That depends on why you’re asking.”
“Because last night was uncomfortable.”
Camille leaned against the counter. “That’s a polite word for it.”
“I was trying to be polite.”
“Elias wasn’t.”
There was a pause.
“No,” Imani said. “He wasn’t.”
Camille waited for the rest.
It came.
“But he wasn’t entirely wrong.”
Camille closed her eyes.
“Of course.”
“Don’t do that.”
“Do what?”
“Turn me into the enemy because I didn’t tell you what you wanted to hear.”
“I didn’t ask you to take sides.”
“You don’t have to. You called me after your argument with him in March. You called when Odessa moved in. You called when you felt like nobody noticed how much extra work landed on you. I know your side.”
“Then you know why last night made me angry.”
“Yes.”
Camille straightened.
Imani added, “And I also know what I saw.”
“What did you see?”
“Your mother-in-law standing at the sink in pain while we sat there laughing.”
Camille’s throat tightened.
“She said she was fine.”
“Camille.”
“What?”
“You saw her holding her back.”
The same sentence had already been spoken in different forms by Elias, Odessa, and now Imani. Repetition gave it weight.
Camille moved to the small window beside the copier.
Below, parents crossed the parking lot toward the private school where she worked as admissions coordinator. Mothers hurried children through the doors. Fathers carried backpacks. A grandmother waited beside a car, buttoning a little boy’s coat while he squirmed.
“I apologized this morning,” Camille said.
“Good.”
“She apologized too.”
“For what?”
“For washing more than I asked her to wash.”
Imani was quiet for a moment.
“That sounds like Odessa.”
Camille laughed weakly. “It does.”
“Did Elias apologize?”
“No.”
“Also sounds like Elias.”
That earned a real laugh.
Then Imani said, “Naomi was upset.”
Camille’s smile faded.
“At me?”
“Not exactly.”
“What does that mean?”
“She said it reminded her of her aunt.”
Camille knew some of Naomi’s family history, but not all of it.
“Her aunt?”
“Her aunt lived with her oldest daughter for six years. Watched the grandkids, cooked, cleaned, did laundry. Everybody called it ‘helping the family.’ When she started having trouble with her knees, they complained that she wasn’t doing as much anymore.”
Camille looked down.
“That’s not what’s happening here.”
“I know.”
“Do you?”
“Yes. But sometimes something doesn’t have to be the worst version of itself to be wrong.”
Camille rubbed her forehead.
“I am so tired of everybody making this one evening into a diagnosis of my character.”
“I’m not diagnosing you.”
“It feels like it.”
“Then let me say something different. I know you. You are not cruel. You are not lazy. You are not somebody who enjoys seeing an old woman suffer.”
Camille swallowed.
“But?”
“But being a good person does not make every choice you make good.”
The copy machine clicked beside her.
Camille stared at the blank wall.
Imani’s voice softened.
“You’ve been angry for months that Elias gets to be the son while you became the manager. I understand that. But I think some of that anger started landing on Odessa because she was the person in the house who needed something.”
Camille did not answer.
She remembered Odessa asking where the extra towels were kept, even though she had been shown twice. Asking whether Tuesday or Wednesday was recycling day. Asking for a ride to the pharmacy because rain was forecast. Asking Camille to help her log into the patient portal because she had forgotten the password.
None of those things had been unreasonable.
Together, they had felt endless.
And Elias had often been at work.
“I never wanted to resent her,” Camille said.
“I know.”
“That makes it worse.”
“Only if you pretend you don’t.”
Camille was silent.
Imani continued. “What are you going to do?”
“Odessa wants to talk about where she’ll live long-term.”
“Maybe that’s good.”
“Elias looked like somebody had suggested exile.”
“Also predictable.”
Camille almost smiled.
Then she remembered something else.
“When he said, ‘She’s not your servant,’ I wanted to disappear.”
“Because it was unfair?”
“Because part of me knew why it looked that way.”
Imani let the silence sit.
Camille glanced at the clock.
“I have to go.”
“Okay.”
“Imani?”
“Yeah?”
“Thank you for staying last night when you asked if you should leave.”
Imani laughed softly. “Your husband told us to stay.”
“I know. But you could have gone anyway.”
“Naomi almost did.”
Camille winced.
“I’ll call her.”
“Give her a little time.”
They hung up.
Camille remained in the copy room another minute.
Then she opened a note on her phone and typed a list.
Doctor appointments.
Pharmacy pickups.
Groceries.
Laundry.
House repairs.
Cooking.
Cleaning.
Bills.
Transportation.
She looked at the words.
For months, she had been using the list as evidence that no one appreciated how much she carried.
May you like
Now another question occurred to her.
Which items had Odessa quietly been carrying too?