scribe

Chapter 18 - The Edited Recording

The defense produced a twenty-eight-second audio clip allegedly recorded on Ms. Cross’s phone. Sophie’s voice said, “Can I get down, please?” Cross replied, “If that helps you calm yourself.” Then Sophie said, “I made the whole thing happen.”

Laura went white. Sophie shook her head violently.

“That’s my voice, but not like that.”

A forensic expert examined the file. Its visible creation date matched the restroom incident, but microscopic breaks in background sound suggested editing. The phrases came from separate conversations.

Sophie remembered one source. Weeks earlier, during a dizzy spell, she had asked to sit down. Cross made her repeat, “I made the whole thing happen,” after Sophie spilled paint water in class.

The original recordings were not on the seized phone, but cloud-sync logs showed multiple audio files uploaded and deleted. Investigators recovered fragments from a backup.

The defense clip had been assembled the evening after Emily complained.

The judge ruled it inadmissible and scheduled a hearing on possible evidence fabrication. Cross’s attorney stated he had received it from his client and did not know it was altered. He withdrew from representation because he might become a witness regarding its origin. The court delayed trial so new counsel could prepare.

Sophie felt crushed.

“Every time we get close, she makes another version of me.”

Dr. Lee asked, “What remains yours no matter how many versions she makes?”

“What really happened.”

“And?”

Sophie thought. “What I choose now.”

She decided to record a private statement—not for court or the press, but for herself. In it, she described the look back.

“I was asking Millie to do something I couldn’t do yet,” she said. “Then I lied and said I never looked. Both things are true: I was brave enough to ask, and scared enough to deny it.”

Millie made her own recording. “I saw a hand raised. I did not see it fall. I saw Sophie afraid. I told my mom. I wish I had done more, but what I did mattered.”

They sealed the recordings with their mothers and agreed to listen again after the case ended.

The new trial date was set for May.

Then the school’s restored email archive revealed one final draft written by Cross but never shared with Warren.

It contained plans to blame him for everything if an investigation began.

Attached was a photograph of the original red folder—every page visible.

May you like

Laura had burned paper.

Cross’s own distrust had preserved the evidence.

Related Stories

Other posts