scribe

Chapter 7 - ELARA’S LIST

The next morning, Elara asked if they could go to a stationery shop.

It was not the request Aveline expected after the previous day.

She had offered the children the Eiffel Tower, a museum, a boat ride, or simply a quiet morning at the hotel. Caelan wanted hot chocolate. Elara wanted a notebook.

They found a small paper shop on a side street where the shelves smelled faintly of cedar and ink. Elara chose a blue clothbound notebook with unlined pages. Caelan chose a packet of postcards showing cartoon pigeons wearing berets.

Back at a café, while Caelan carefully addressed one postcard to his mother, Elara opened her new notebook and began copying something from an older folded paper she had taken from her backpack.

Aveline saw the title.

THINGS I SHOULD NOT ASK FOR.

She stopped breathing for half a second.

“Elara.”

Her daughter looked up.

“What is that?”

Elara instinctively covered the page with her hand.

“Nothing.”

Aveline forced herself not to reach for it.

“You don’t have to show me. But I saw the heading.”

Elara looked down.

Caelan had stopped writing.

“It’s just a list.”

“Who told you to make it?”

“No one.”

That answer was worse.

Aveline waited.

Eventually Elara slid the old paper across the table.

The handwriting was uneven but careful.

New ballet shoes before mine are too small.

Piano again.

The science camp because it costs a lot.

A better tablet.

Birthday restaurant if Caelan doesn’t like it.

Business class.

Aveline stared at the last line.

It had been added in darker pencil, probably at the airport.

“Elara, why do you have this?”

Her daughter rubbed the rabbit’s ear between two fingers.

“Evren says I have to remember I already have more.”

“How often does he say that?”

Elara shrugged.

“Sometimes.”

“What does ‘sometimes’ mean?”

“When I ask for stuff.”

Aveline felt guilt rise hot behind her ribs.

“Did he tell you not to ask me?”

“No. He says asking you puts you in a bad position because you’ll feel guilty and say yes.”

Aveline closed her eyes briefly.

That sounded exactly like Evren—pressure disguised as protection.

“What happened with piano?”

“I said I wanted to start again after school got easier. He said lessons were expensive and Caelan needed swimming because it was a safety thing.”

“I would have paid for both.”

“I know.”

“Then why didn’t you tell me?”

Elara’s eyes filled, but she did not cry.

“Because he said that was the problem.”

Aveline leaned closer.

“What problem?”

“That you always make things equal by spending more money. He said real fairness means sometimes I should get less because I started with more.”

Across the table, Caelan looked stricken.

“My swimming isn’t because of you.”

“I know,” Elara said quickly.

“I can stop.”

“No.”

“Then you can do piano.”

Aveline watched the children attempt in ten seconds what the adults had failed to do for years: refuse the idea that one child’s opportunity required the other child’s loss.

She reached across the table and turned the old list over.

“Elara, may I write something on the back?”

Her daughter nodded.

Aveline wrote:

THINGS YOU ARE ALLOWED TO ASK FOR.

Then underneath:

Anything.

She slid the paper back.

“That does not mean the answer will always be yes. Sometimes the answer will be no because of time, money, safety, or other reasons. But you are allowed to ask. You are not responsible for calculating the family’s fairness before you speak.”

Elara read the words.

“What if it costs a lot?”

“You can still ask.”

“What if Caelan doesn’t get the same thing?”

“Different children can need or want different things. Fairness is not making you disappear until the numbers match.”

Caelan raised his hand as though he were in school.

“Can I ask something?”

“Yes.”

“Can I not go to boarding school?”

Aveline swallowed.

“You can absolutely say you do not want to go. Your parents will have to make the final school decisions, but your feelings should be heard clearly.”

He nodded.

Elara looked at him.

“Put it on a list.”

Caelan smiled faintly.

He turned over one of his postcards and wrote in large block letters:

I DO NOT WANT TO LIVE AT SCHOOL.

Aveline took a picture of it with his permission.

Not as evidence.

As a promise to herself not to let adult plans speak louder than the child they concerned.

Her phone rang.

Saskia Bell.

Caelan’s biological mother.

Aveline had texted her earlier asking for a call when she was free.

She answered.

“Aveline? Is Caelan okay?” Saskia asked immediately.

“He’s safe. He’s with me.”

“What happened?”

Aveline looked at Caelan.

“I need to ask whether Evren discussed St. Aldwyn’s Preparatory Academy with you.”

There was a long silence.

Then Saskia said, “What is St. Aldwyn’s?”

Caelan’s postcard lay on the table between them.

I DO NOT WANT TO LIVE AT SCHOOL.

Aveline realized the secret was no longer contained inside her marriage.

Before they left the café, Elara tore the old list from her notebook, then stopped with the page halfway free.

"I thought I wanted to throw it away."

Aveline waited.

Elara smoothed the page instead. "I think I want to keep it so I know which ideas were mine and which ones I learned."

Aveline nodded. "That sounds useful."

Caelan pointed at the line about business class. "Can you add that I didn't agree?"

Elara handed him the pencil.

He wrote beside it in crooked letters: CAELAN DID NOT ASK FOR THIS.

May you like

Neither child laughed.

Then Elara folded the page and placed it in the back pocket of the notebook.

Related Stories

Other posts